Winemaking Laboratory

Chapter VII · Sensory science and tasting

Wine faults

A fault is a change in wine that lowers its quality: the mouldy smell of cork taint, the "farmyard" of Brettanomyces, vinegar, oxidation, rotten egg. How to recognise a fault by its symptoms, at what concentration Brettanomyces phenols and volatile acidity become a problem, and what can be done.

What do you notice?

Smell

Appearance and taste

Conditions

The diagnosis sums weighted symptoms and only points you in a direction. Most faults are confirmed in the laboratory: TCA by GC-MS, Brettanomyces by 4-ethylphenol and microscopy/PCR, volatile acidity by distillation, oxidation by acetaldehyde and free SO₂. The "severity" of a fault depends on thresholds: some compounds add complexity at low levels and spoil the wine at high levels.

Most likely—
Second—
Threshold—
What to do—

Analysis

Perception thresholds (Chatonnet et al., 1992): 4-ethylphenol ≈ 425 µg/L, 4-ethylguaiacol ≈ 110 µg/L; in a typical ≈ 10:1 mixture Brettanomyces character is perceived from a total of ≈ 400 µg/L, by some people earlier. 4-EP gives horse sweat and sticking plaster, 4-EG smoke and clove. Molecular SO₂ = free / (1 + 10^(pH − 1.81)); ≥ 0.6 mg/L is needed to control Brettanomyces (0.5–0.8 according to some sources).

4-Ethylphenol—µg/L
4-Ethylguaiacol—µg/L
Brettanomyces character—
Molecular SO₂—mg/L

Volatile acidity

EU limits: white and rosé 18 meq/L (1.08 g/L as acetic acid), red 20 meq/L (1.20 g/L); some aged and sweet wines have exemptions. Conversion: 1 meq/L = 0.060 g/L acetic acid = 0.049 g/L H₂SO₄. Acetic acid is perceived from ≈ 0.7–1.2 g/L; ethyl acetate below 80 mg/L gives a fruity note, above 150 mg/L a glue/acetone smell. Some sources treat high VA in qvevri wine as part of the style; it is not a norm.

As acetic acid—g/L
Of the legal limit—%
Perception—
Ethyl acetate—

What is a fault

A wine fault is a change that lowers the quality of the wine and that experienced tasters judge negatively. Some compounds in small amounts are part of a wine's complexity (for example, a little volatile acidity or a trace of 4-ethylphenol) and become a fault only above a threshold. Most faults are microbiological, some chemical, and some come from outside sources.

The main faults

FaultSmellCompoundThreshold
Cork taintmould, wet cardboard2,4,6-trichloroanisole (TCA)1–4 ng/L
Brettanomyceshorse sweat, sticking plaster, smoke4-ethylphenol, 4-ethylguaiacol425 / 110 µg/L
Volatile acidityvinegar; glue, acetoneacetic acid; ethyl acetate0.7–1.2 g/L; 150 mg/L
Oxidationsherry, bruised appleacetaldehyde≈ 100 mg/L
Reductionrotten egg; onion, rubberH₂S; mercaptans≈ 1; ≈ 2 µg/L
Light strikecooked cabbagemethanethiol, DMDS—
Mousy taintmouse, biscuit (in the mouth)tetrahydropyridinesindividual
Geraniumgeranium leaf2-ethoxyhexa-3,5-diene≈ 0.1 µg/L
Smoke taintsmoke, ashguaiacol, 4-methylguaiacol6–23 µg/L

Cork taint (TCA)

2,4,6-Trichloroanisole is formed by moulds from chlorophenols, residues of wood treatments and chlorine-based cleaners. TCA reaches wine mainly from the cork, but can also come from cellar timber, barrels and plastic hoses, in which case the whole batch is affected. It is so potent that even a sub-threshold dose "mutes" the fruit aroma. Chlorine-based products should not be used in the cellar.

Brettanomyces

The yeast Brettanomyces bruxellensis develops slowly in wine, especially with high pH, low SO₂, residual sugar and poorly cleaned barrels. It converts the grape's hydroxycinnamic acids (p-coumaric and ferulic acids) via vinylphenols into 4-ethylphenol and 4-ethylguaiacol. Its hallmarks are "horse sweat", "farmyard" and "sticking plaster"; some winemakers consider a little "Brett" to be complexity, most a fault.

The main tool for controlling Brettanomyces is molecular SO₂:

$$SO_{2,mol} = \frac{SO_{2,free}}{1 + 10^{\,pH - 1.81}} \geq 0.6\ \text{mg/L}.$$

At pH 3.4 about 24 mg/L of free SO₂ is enough, while at pH 3.8 about 60 mg/L is needed.

Volatile acidity

More than 90% of volatile acidity (VA) is acetic acid. It is produced by acetic bacteria (Acetobacter), which need oxygen, so VA rises in empty, untopped vessels, on a dry pomace cap and during open fermentation. Part is also produced by lactic acid bacteria and yeast. Ethyl acetate is the ester of acetic acid and ethanol, with a smell of glue or acetone.

EU limits: white and rosé wine 18 meq/L (1.08 g/L as acetic acid), red 20 meq/L (1.20 g/L). In some countries VA is expressed as sulphuric acid (H₂SO₄): 1 g/L acetic acid = 0.817 g/L H₂SO₄.

Oxidation and reduction

Too much oxygen oxidises wine: the colour darkens (white turns yellow then brown, red turns brick), and the "sherry" and bruised-apple smell of acetaldehyde appears. Too little oxygen causes reductive smells: hydrogen sulphide and mercaptans (see Chapter IV "Oxygen in wine"). Both are a matter of oxygen management.

Other faults

• Light strike: UV light, with the participation of riboflavin, breaks down methionine; a white wine in clear glass is damaged within a few hours.

• Mousy taint: a product of lactic acid bacteria or Brettanomyces that is hardly noticeable on the nose but appears in the mouth, at the pH of saliva, after swallowing. It affects high-pH, low-SO₂ wines, including "natural" wines made without SO₂.

• Geranium smell: sorbic acid + lactic acid bacteria.

• Refermentation in bottle: fermentation of residual sugar or malic acid; bubbles, haze, pressure.

• Surface film and ropiness: aerobic yeast on the surface and bacterial polysaccharides.

• Smoke taint: phenols from bushfire smoke enter the grape and are released during fermentation or in the bottle.

Prevention

Preventing most faults rests on four rules: cleanliness (vessels, cellar, hoses, without chlorine), topping up (against oxygen and aerobic microbes), the right SO₂ level for the pH, and regular tasting and analysis of the wine.

Sources

P. Ribéreau-Gayon et al., "Handbook of Enology", vols 1–2 (wine diseases and faults); P. Chatonnet et al., "The origin of ethylphenols in wines", J. Sci. Food Agric. 60 (1992); AWRI materials on Brettanomyces and smoke taint; P. Grbin, P. Henschke, on mousy taint; EU Regulation 2019/934 (volatile acidity limits). Thresholds are typical values from the literature.

How to use this page

1. In the "Diagnosis" mode, tick the symptoms: smell, appearance, taste and conditions. The chart shows a score for each fault, and the cards show the most likely fault, its cause, threshold and what can be done.

2. In the "Brettanomyces" mode, enter laboratory results for 4-ethylphenol and 4-ethylguaiacol, along with pH and free SO₂. You will see how close the compounds are to the perception threshold and whether the wine is protected against Brettanomyces.

3. In the "Volatile acidity" mode, enter the measured VA in any unit and, if you have it, ethyl acetate. You will see the value as acetic acid, the percentage of the legal limit and the level of perception.

Practical tips

• Smell and taste your wine regularly: a fault is easier to fix at an early stage.

• Act immediately on a smell of H₂S (rotten egg): rack with aeration, stir, and if necessary run a copper bench trial (see Chapter IV). Over time H₂S turns into mercaptans and disulphides, which are much harder to remove.

• Keep vessels always full. A white film or a vinegar smell is a sign of air.

• Do not use chlorine-based products in the cellar or for washing vessels: they are a source of TCA.

• In high-pH wine (> 3.6) raise SO₂ accordingly: the risk of Brettanomyces and mousy taint is highest in these wines.

• When in doubt, send a sample to a laboratory: an accurate diagnosis is the basis of the right decision.

1. Which compound causes cork taint?

TCA is formed by moulds from chlorophenols. It is perceptible at a few nanograms per litre and mutes the fruity aroma of wine. The source may be the cork, but also cellar timber and barrels.

2. What protects wine from Brettanomyces?

Brettanomyces thrives in wine with high pH, low SO₂ and poorly cleaned barrels. Molecular SO₂ depends on pH: at pH 3.8, ≈ 60 mg/L of free SO₂ is needed for 0.6 mg/L.

3. Why does a geranium smell appear?

Potassium sorbate acts against yeast but not against bacteria. If lactic acid bacteria are active in the wine, they turn sorbic acid into a very potent odorant. That is why sorbate is used only with SO₂ and without MLF.