Winemaking Laboratory

Chapter VI · Modern technology and ageing

The oak barrel

An oak barrel gives wine three things: wood aroma (vanillin, oak lactone, toasty notes), tannin, and a slow, measured supply of oxygen. What depends on barrel size, oak origin, toast level and age, and how to replace a barrel with oak pieces.

Barrel and cellar

The inner surface of a barrel is ≈ 2.0·(V/225)^(2/3) m². Oxygen: a new barrique (225 L) ≈ 30 mg/L per year, proportional to surface-to-volume, less in an old barrel (pores fill with tartrate and deposits). Evaporation depends on temperature and humidity: ≈ 2–5% per year. In a dry cellar more water evaporates and the wine gains alcohol; in a humid one, the reverse. The results are estimates.

Surface / volume—cm²/L
Oxygen—mg/L
Evaporation—L
Change in alcohol—%

Oak and barrel

The model is illustrative: in a new, medium-toast French barrique after 12 months ≈ vanillin 0.3, oak lactone 0.15, guaiacol 0.03 mg/L, ellagitannins ≈ 150 mg/L. American oak has ≈ 3 times more lactone and ≈ 2.5 times less ellagitannin. Heavy toast raises guaiacol and lowers ellagitannin and lactone. Each further use roughly halves the potential. There are few data on Georgian oak; here it is taken as similar to French with slightly more lactone. OAV = concentration / perception threshold (in red wine: vanillin 0.32, lactone 0.074, guaiacol 0.075 mg/L); OAV > 1 means the aroma is perceptible.

Vanillin—mg/L
Oak lactone—mg/L
Guaiacol (toasty)—mg/L
Ellagitannins—mg/L

Wine and oak

The EU allows oak pieces in winemaking (Reg. 2019/934): ≥ 95% of the pieces (by weight) must be retained by a 2 mm sieve, so oak powder is not allowed. Guide: the effect of a new barrique ≈ 3 g/L of chips, ≈ 5 g/L of cubes, or staves with the same surface as a barrique (≈ 90 cm²/L). A stave is ≈ 95 × 5 × 0.7 cm, both sides ≈ 0.1 m². Extraction time (90%): chips ≈ 3–4 weeks, cubes ≈ 2 months, staves ≈ 4–6 months. Oak pieces give no oxygen; for that you need micro-oxygenation or careful racking.

Dose—g/L
Total oak—
Extraction at the end of contact—%
Effect achieved—%

Oak and wine

The oak barrel has held wine since Roman times, at first simply as a durable, portable container. Today it is used for three things:

1. Wood aroma: vanillin, oak lactone (coconut), eugenol (clove), guaiacol and 4-methylguaiacol (smoky, toasty notes), furfural (almond, caramel).

2. Tannin: the hydrolysable tannins of the wood (ellagitannins: vescalagin, castalagin), which give the wine astringency and structure and take part in oxidation reactions.

3. Oxygen: through the barrel wall, between the staves and through the bung hole the wine slowly picks up oxygen. This helps tannins polymerise, stabilises colour and "softens" the wine.

Barrel size

The influence of a barrel is set by its surface-to-volume ratio ($S/V$). Surface grows as volume to the power 2/3:

$$S \approx 2.0\left(\frac{V}{225}\right)^{2/3}\ \text{m}^2, \qquad \frac{S}{V} \propto V^{-1/3}.$$

BarrelVolume, LS/V, cm²/L
Barrique (Bordeaux)225≈ 89
Burgundy228≈ 88
Hogshead300≈ 81
Puncheon500≈ 68
Demi-muid600≈ 64
Foudre2000–10000≈ 43–25

A small barrel oaks the wine quickly and strongly; a large one slowly and gently, mainly through oxygen. Oxygen ingress in a new barrique is ≈ 20–40 mg/L per year; less in an old barrel whose pores fill with tartrate and deposits.

Evaporation

Wine evaporates through the barrel wall, ≈ 2–5% a year (the "angels' share"). Water and alcohol evaporate at different rates, depending on cellar humidity: in dry air (humidity < 70%) more water evaporates and the alcohol of the wine rises; in humid air (> 80%) more alcohol evaporates and it falls. The space that forms above the wine must be topped up regularly, or oxidation and acetic bacteria develop.

Oak species and origin

• French oak (Quercus petraea, sessile oak; Q. robur, pedunculate oak): dense, fine-grained, rich in ellagitannin. Gives a fine, tannic structure and delicate vanilla.

• American white oak (Quercus alba): several times richer in oak lactone, poor in ellagitannin. Gives a sweet coconut and vanilla aroma.

• Caucasian oak: the Georgian oak (Quercus iberica) growing in Georgia and other species. Traditionally used for barrels for Georgian brandy and wine. Its chemistry is close to French sessile oak, though systematic data are scarce.

The wood is seasoned in the open air for years (usually 2–3). During this time part of the bitter tannins are washed out and aroma precursors form.

Toasting

When a barrel is made, the staves are bent over fire and charred on the inside. Toasting breaks down the wood polymers: lignin gives vanillin and guaiacol, hemicellulose gives furfural and caramel notes, and ellagitannins are partly destroyed.

ToastVanillinLactoneGuaiacolEllagitannin
Lightmoderatehighlowhigh
Mediumhighmoderatemoderatemoderate
Heavymoderatelowhighlow

Extraction kinetics

The concentration of each compound rises roughly as

$$C(t) = C_{max}\bigl(1 - e^{-t/\tau}\bigr),$$

where $\tau$ is a few months. Ellagitannins come out quickly but then decline through oxidation, polymerisation and precipitation. Each further use roughly halves the potential of the barrel; after 4–5 years the barrel is aromatically neutral but still lets oxygen through.

The "strength" of an aroma is characterised by the ratio to its perception threshold (OAV): $OAV = C / C_{thr}$. If OAV > 1 the compound is perceptible. In red wine the perception thresholds are roughly: vanillin 0.32, oak lactone 0.074, guaiacol 0.075 mg/L.

Oak pieces

Instead of barrels, oak pieces (chips, cubes, staves) placed directly in the tank are often used. They are cheap and give wood aroma quickly, but no oxygen, so they are often combined with micro-oxygenation. In the EU oak pieces are allowed (Reg. 2019/934) if ≥ 95% of the pieces (by weight) are retained by a 2 mm sieve; oak powder is not allowed. Oak pieces are prohibited for some wines with a protected designation.

Sources

P. Ribéreau-Gayon et al., "Handbook of Enology", vol. 2 (ageing in oak barrels); P. Chatonnet, D. Dubourdieu, "Comparative study of the characteristics of American white oak and European oak for production of barrels used in barrel aging of wines", AJEV 49 (1998); A. Prida, P. Chatonnet, on oak lactone and toasting; EU Regulation 2019/934. The model numbers are illustrative.

How to use this page

1. In the "Barrel size" mode, enter the barrel volume, age, ageing time and the cellar temperature and humidity. You will see the surface-to-volume ratio, oxygen, evaporation (how much to top up per month) and the change in alcohol. The chart shows how S/V falls with barrel size.

2. In the "Aroma extraction" mode, choose the oak origin, toast, barrel age and volume. The cards show the concentration of vanillin, oak lactone, guaiacol and ellagitannins at the end of ageing, and how perceptible they are (OAV).

3. In the "Oak pieces" mode, enter the wine volume, form, desired effect (as % of a new barrel) and contact time. You will see the dose, the total amount of oak (for staves, the number of staves) and the degree of extraction.

Practical tips

• Swell a new barrel with clean water and check for leaks. Smoke an old barrel with sulphur and store it dry.

• Top up the barrel with the same wine every 2–4 weeks. Empty space causes oxidation and acetic bacteria.

• Taste the effect of a new barrel regularly: wood easily overwhelms a light wine. Wine is often aged in a mix of new and old barrels.

• Put oak pieces in a nylon or cloth bag so they are easy to remove.

• Qvevri wine traditionally needs no oak: skin contact gives it enough tannin and structure.

The model numbers are illustrative and depend on the cooper, the wood quality and the wine.

1. Why does a small barrel give wine more oak influence than a large one?

Surface grows as volume to the power 2/3, so S/V ∝ V^(−1/3). In a 225 L barrique there are ≈ 90 cm² of wood per litre, in a 600 L barrel ≈ 65, and in a large cask much less.

2. How does American oak differ from French?

Quercus alba contains several times more oak lactone (cis-whisky lactone) and less soluble ellagitannin. American oak therefore gives a sweeter coconut and vanilla aroma, French a finer, more tannic structure.

3. What can oak chips not do compared with a barrel?

Chips and staves give wood aroma and tannin, but in a steel tank no oxygen comes through the wall. For the full barrel effect they are often combined with micro-oxygenation.