Chapter IV · Stabilisation and clarification
Why the SO₂ you add and the SO₂ you measure do not match: what it binds to in wine, how much to add so the wine is protected and stays within the legal limit, and how free SO₂ declines in storage.
Bound SO₂ is calculated from the bisulphite equilibrium with each compound: bound = C·[HSO₃⁻]/(Kd + [HSO₃⁻]). Kd (mol/L): acetaldehyde 1.5·10⁻⁶, pyruvate 3·10⁻⁴, α-ketoglutarate 5·10⁻⁴, anthocyanins ≈ 3·10⁻⁵, glucose 0.6. Molecular SO₂: pKa 1.81. The result is approximate: other compounds also bind in real wine.
Part of the added SO₂ binds immediately to acetaldehyde and keto acids; this share is calculated with the model from the first mode. Limits under EU law (2019/934): dry red 150, dry white and rosé 200 mg/L; with more than 5 g/L sugar, 200 and 250 mg/L. Measure again 1–2 days after an addition.
Each 1 mg/L of oxygen uses up ≈ 4 mg/L of SO₂ (a maximum; phenolics take some of it). When free SO₂ falls below 75% of the target, the calculation adds back to the target, and part of each addition binds. Total SO₂ rises with every addition.
Sulphiting the must (Chapter II, "Preparing the must") concerns the start of fermentation: it restrains wild microbes and oxidising enzymes. After fermentation SO₂ has a different job: to protect the wine from oxygen, vinegar bacteria, Brettanomyces and, in some cases, unwanted malolactic fermentation, over months and years. During this time SO₂ is added to the wine several times: after the malolactic fermentation (or after the alcoholic fermentation if you do not want MLF), in storage, at rackings and before bottling.
The winemaker adds SO₂ and then measures it, but the numbers almost never match: of 50 mg/L added, free SO₂ may rise by only 25–35 mg/L. The reason is chemical: part of the SO₂ binds to compounds in the wine.
SO₂ dissolved in water exists in three forms, whose proportions depend on pH:
$$SO_2 + H_2O \rightleftharpoons HSO_3^- + H^+ \quad (pK_{a1} \approx 1.81)$$
$$HSO_3^- \rightleftharpoons SO_3^{2-} + H^+ \quad (pK_{a2} \approx 7.2)$$
At wine pH (3–4), 94–99% of free SO₂ is the bisulphite ion (HSO₃⁻), 1–6% is molecular SO₂, and there is practically no sulphite ion. Only molecular SO₂ kills microbes: it is electrically neutral and passes through the cell membrane. Bisulphite is an antioxidant and inhibits enzymes.
$$SO_2^{\text{mol}} = \frac{SO_2^{\text{free}}}{1 + 10^{\,pH - pK_{a1}}}$$
pKa₁ = 1.81 is the value for water at 20 °C. In wine, alcohol and ionic strength raise it slightly (≈ 1.9–2.0), so the real molecular share is a little higher than calculated: the calculation errs on the safe side.
The bisulphite ion binds to carbonyl compounds (aldehydes, ketones), forming hydroxysulphonates:
$$R{-}CHO + HSO_3^- \rightleftharpoons R{-}CH(OH){-}SO_3^-$$
This is a reversible reaction, characterised by a dissociation constant:
$$K_d = \frac{[\text{compound}]\,[HSO_3^-]}{[\text{complex}]} \qquad SO_2^{\text{bound}} = C\cdot\frac{[HSO_3^-]}{K_d + [HSO_3^-]}$$
The smaller Kd, the more firmly the compound binds SO₂.
| Compound | Typical content in wine | Kd, mol/L | How much it binds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acetaldehyde | 10–80 mg/L (more in oxidised wine) | 1.5·10⁻⁶ | almost completely: 1 mg → 1.45 mg SO₂ |
| Pyruvic acid | 10–100 mg/L | 3·10⁻⁴ | partly |
| α-Ketoglutaric acid | 20–150 mg/L | 5·10⁻⁴ | partly |
| Anthocyanins | 0 (white) – 500 mg/L (young red) | ≈ 3·10⁻⁵ | considerably, bleaching the colour |
| Glucose | 1–100 g/L | 0.6 | little, but noticeably in sweet wine |
Acetaldehyde is the main "binder". Yeast produces it during fermentation (especially when the must has a lot of SO₂ at the start of fermentation: the yeast protects itself by releasing acetaldehyde), and in wine it forms during oxidation. An oxidised wine therefore needs much more SO₂: until all the acetaldehyde is bound, free SO₂ will hardly rise. Pyruvic and α-ketoglutaric acids are products of yeast metabolism; after malolactic fermentation the bacteria break down part of them, so after MLF less SO₂ is bound.
When SO₂ binds to anthocyanins, red wine loses colour (bisulphite turns the anthocyanin into a colourless form). This is reversible: as SO₂ is used up, the colour returns. With age, anthocyanins turn into polymeric pigments, which no longer bind SO₂.
Bound SO₂ gives the wine almost no protection, but two things matter: it counts towards the legal limit (total SO₂ = free + bound), and as free SO₂ falls, part of it is released again, because the equilibrium shifts.
The target is set by molecular SO₂: 0.8 mg/L for white and rosé wine, 0.5–0.6 mg/L for red and amber (phenolics add protection). The free SO₂ needed is:
$$SO_2^{\text{free}} = SO_2^{\text{mol}}\cdot\left(1 + 10^{\,pH - 1.81}\right)$$
| pH | For 0.8 mg/L molecular | For 0.5 mg/L molecular |
|---|---|---|
| 3.0 | 13 mg/L | 8 mg/L |
| 3.2 | 20 mg/L | 13 mg/L |
| 3.4 | 32 mg/L | 20 mg/L |
| 3.6 | 50 mg/L | 31 mg/L |
| 3.8 | 79 mg/L | 49 mg/L |
A wine with pH above 3.7–3.8 is practically impossible to protect with SO₂: the free SO₂ needed can be smelled and the total approaches the limit. For such a wine, raising the acidity (Chapter II, "Acids and pH"), strict hygiene, low temperature and early bottling are better.
When adding, remember that part of the addition binds. If the wine already has enough free SO₂ (the acetaldehyde is bound), 10–30% of the addition binds; if free SO₂ is close to zero, much more.
Free SO₂ gradually declines in storage, mainly because of oxygen. Oxygen oxidises phenolics in wine and forms hydrogen peroxide; SO₂ reduces the peroxide and the oxidised phenolics (quinones) and is itself turned into sulphate. Stoichiometrically two moles of SO₂ are used per mole of oxygen:
$$1\ \text{mg}\ O_2 \;\rightarrow\; \approx 4\ \text{mg}\ SO_2$$
This is a maximum; in reality phenolics and other compounds take part of the oxygen, so the consumption is often 2.5–4 mg. SO₂ turned into sulphate disappears from both free and total SO₂.
Oxygen reaches wine in two ways: continuously (through vessel walls, the closure and the headspace) and during operations (racking, pumping, filtration, bottling, 0.5–6 mg/L each). That is why free SO₂ should be measured before and after each operation. In addition, part of the bound SO₂ is slowly released and used up, and some leaves the wine by evaporation (in an open vessel).
In the EU (Regulation 2019/934) the limits for total SO₂ are: dry red wine 150 mg/L, dry white and rosé 200 mg/L; with more than 5 g/L sugar, 200 and 250 mg/L; some sweet wines are allowed more. Organic wines have stricter limits. More than 10 mg/L of SO₂ must be declared on the label ("contains sulphites"), because some people (especially asthmatics) react to sulphites.
No other agent fully replaces SO₂: ascorbic acid captures oxygen quickly, but without SO₂ it actually speeds up oxidation; lysozyme inhibits lactic acid bacteria but not yeasts; chitosan is used against Brettanomyces. Wine can be made without SO₂, but it requires complete hygiene, low pH, protection from oxygen and low temperature. The qvevri, which keeps the wine cool in the ground and protected by the phenolics of the pomace, is a good example.
1. In the "Free and bound" mode choose the wine type: typical amounts of acetaldehyde, keto acids, anthocyanins and sugar are filled in automatically (if you have a laboratory analysis, enter your own numbers). From free SO₂ and pH you will see total and bound SO₂, molecular SO₂, and which compound binds the most. The chart shows how bound SO₂ grows as free SO₂ rises.
2. In the "Calculating an addition" mode enter the current free and total SO₂, pH, the target molecular SO₂ and the wine volume. You get the free SO₂ needed, how much to add (allowing for binding), grams of metabisulphite or millilitres of SO₂ solution, and the total SO₂ after the addition, compared with the legal limit.
3. In the "Decline in storage" mode choose the vessel, storage time and number of rackings. The calculation shows when the wine will need its first addition, how many additions and how much SO₂ will be added in total, and what the total SO₂ will be at the end.
• Add SO₂ as soon as alcoholic fermentation is finished if you do not want malolactic fermentation (white wine), or as soon as MLF is finished (red, amber). The period between the end of fermentation and the SO₂ addition is the most dangerous: CO₂ no longer protects the wine, and there is no SO₂ yet.
• At the first addition the wine binds a lot: add 40–60 mg/L and measure 1–2 days later. Later additions bind less.
• Dissolve the metabisulphite beforehand in a little wine or water and mix it well through the whole volume: in a large vessel SO₂ does not spread by itself.
• Check free SO₂ before and after every racking, pumping or filtration, and in storage every 1–2 months (in an oak barrel, every month).
• Before bottling bring free SO₂ to the upper end of the target: the wine takes up oxygen during bottling, and SO₂ falls further in the bottle.
• If the wine smells of SO₂ (a "struck match" smell), free SO₂ is too high. Do not add more: it will decline by itself in storage. Racking with air contact reduces it quickly.
• Record every addition in a journal: date, dose, measured free and total SO₂. This way you will see how much SO₂ your wine and your vessel "eat".
1. You added 50 mg/L SO₂ to a wine, and two days later free SO₂ had risen by only 30 mg/L. Where did the rest go?
Bisulphite binds to carbonyl compounds. Acetaldehyde captures it almost completely, keto acids partly. This bound SO₂ gives almost no protection against microbes, but it counts towards the legal limit.
2. Why does a wine need much more SO₂ after it has oxidised (when acetaldehyde has built up)?
The molecular mass of acetaldehyde is 44 and that of SO₂ is 64; they combine 1:1. Until all the acetaldehyde is bound, free SO₂ will hardly rise.
3. In an oak barrel wine takes up ≈ 2.5 mg/L of oxygen per month. How much SO₂ does that use up per month?
1 mg of oxygen oxidises at most ≈ 4 mg of SO₂. That is why free SO₂ in a barrel should be measured and topped up every 1–2 months.