Winemaking Laboratory
Stabilisation and clarification / Tartrate (cold) stabilisation

Chapter IV · Stabilisation and clarification

Tartrate (cold) stabilisation

Why glass-like crystals appear in the bottle or in a cold cellar, how to judge how stable a wine is, at what temperature and for how long it should be chilled, and what alternatives exist: metatartaric acid, CMC, mannoproteins.

Wine analysis

Concentration product CP = [K⁺]·[HT⁻], where HT⁻ is the share of tartaric acid in the bitartrate form at the given pH (pKa 3.04 and 4.37). KHT solubility uses an approximate model: in water 2.4·e^(0.044T) g/L, reduced by alcohol by a factor e^(−0.058·A). The saturation temperature (T_sat) is the temperature at which the wine is exactly saturated. Würdig criterion: white is stable if T_sat ≤ 12.5 °C, red if T_sat ≤ 10.8 + 0.297·TPI.

Saturation temperature—°C
Supersaturation at storage temperature—×
Could precipitate—g/L
Verdict—

Chilling

The freezing point of wine is ≈ −(0.45·A + 0.8) °C (≈ −6 °C at 12%; sugar and extract lower it further). The usual chilling temperature is −(A/2 − 1) °C. Crystallisation uses an approximate model: supersaturation decays exponentially, statically with τ ≈ 4 days after a 2-day induction (twice as slow in red), with the contact method τ ≈ 1.5 h. Each 1 g/L of KHT precipitated lowers acidity by 0.4 g/L.

Freezing point—°C
Recommended temperature—°C
KHT precipitated—g/L
Chilling energy—kWh

Additive

Additives do not remove crystals: they inhibit crystal growth (attaching to the growth "nuclei"). Metatartaric acid gradually hydrolyses and loses its protection: ≈ 3 months at 20 °C, ten times longer for every 10 °C cooler (approximately). CMC only in white and rosé wine, after protein stabilisation. Doses are within EU limits.

Amount needed—g
Duration of protection—
Suitable—
Note—

Tartrate: what it is and why it appears

Tartrate (wine stone) is potassium hydrogen tartrate (potassium bitartrate, KHT), the salt of tartaric acid and potassium. Grapes contain plenty of both: tartaric acid is their main acid, and the vine takes up potassium from the soil. KHT dissolves well in must, but after fermentation two things change: alcohol appears, which lowers KHT solubility, and the wine cools down. So young wine is often supersaturated with KHT, and the excess salt slowly crystallises: as a crust on the walls and bottom of the vessel, and in the bottle as glass-like crystals. In red wine the crystals are stained by colour and show as a dark deposit at the bottom of the bottle.

Tartrate is harmless and barely changes the taste, but crystals in the bottle put buyers off. So a wine that will end up in a fridge or a cold place in bottle needs stabilisation. Qvevri wine, which spends the winter in the ground at a cool temperature, naturally deposits its tartrate on the bottom and walls of the qvevri: this is traditional cold stabilisation.

A second, less common deposit is calcium tartrate. It crystallises slowly (over months, often already in the bottle), depends little on temperature and is not removed by cold stabilisation. Calcium gets into wine from concrete tanks, from deacidification with calcium carbonate and from some bentonites.

Solubility and the concentration product

KHT solubility is described by an equilibrium:

$$KHT_{(\text{solid})} \rightleftharpoons K^+ + HT^-, \qquad K_{sp} = [K^+]\cdot[HT^-]$$

The wine's actual concentration product (CP) is calculated from the concentrations of potassium and the bitartrate ion. Tartaric acid exists in wine in three forms (H₂T, HT⁻, T²⁻), and the bitartrate share depends on pH; it is greatest at pH ≈ 3.65:

$$CP = [K^+]\cdot C_{\text{tart}}\cdot\alpha_{HT^-}(pH), \qquad \alpha_{HT^-} = \frac{[H^+]K_1}{[H^+]^2 + [H^+]K_1 + K_1K_2}$$

If CP > Ksp, the wine is supersaturated and KHT will precipitate. Ksp is a steep function of temperature and alcohol: in a 12% wine KHT solubility is ≈ 2.9 g/L at 20 °C and ≈ 1.2 g/L at 0 °C, two and a half times less. That is why a wine that is stable in the cellar at 15 °C can crystallise in the fridge.

In real wine this simple picture is more complicated: part of the tartaric acid and potassium is in complexes with other compounds, and colloids (proteins, polysaccharides, tannins, anthocyanins) hinder the formation and growth of crystal nuclei. So wine can often remain supersaturated for a long time. Red wine, with plenty of phenolics and colloids, is much more stable than white at the same CP.

Saturation temperature

In practice a good measure of stability is the saturation temperature (T_sat): the temperature at which the wine is exactly saturated with KHT. Above it the wine can still dissolve KHT; below it the wine is supersaturated. In the laboratory T_sat is measured by electrical conductivity: KHT powder is added to the wine and it is measured whether it dissolves (conductivity rises) at different temperatures. The empirical Würdig criterion:

WineStable if
WhiteT_sat ≤ 12.5 °C
RedT_sat ≤ 10.8 + 0.297·TPI °C (TPI: total phenolics index)

The calculator on this page computes T_sat with an approximate solubility model; the result is a guide, not a replacement for a laboratory measurement.

Cold stabilisation

The most common method is to chill the wine close to its freezing point so that the excess KHT precipitates before the wine goes into bottle. The freezing point of wine depends on alcohol and extract: a 12% wine freezes at ≈ −6 °C. The stabilisation temperature is usually 1 °C above this point:

$$T_{\text{stab}} \approx -\left(\frac{A}{2} - 1\right)\ °C$$

In the static method the wine is held at this temperature for 1–3 weeks. Crystallisation starts with an induction period (nuclei must form first), then slowly approaches equilibrium; in red wine this is slower. Finally the wine must be racked off the crystals or filtered while still cold: as it warms, the crystals partly dissolve again.

In the contact method fine KHT crystals (≈ 4 g/L) are added to the wine and stirred. Crystals grow immediately on the ready surface, and stabilisation is complete in 1–4 hours, even at a slightly higher temperature (up to 0 °C). The crystals are then collected by filtration and can be reused.

Side effects of cold stabilisation: acidity falls (each 1 g/L of KHT ≈ 0.4 g/L as tartaric), and pH changes: if the wine's pH is below 3.65 the pH falls slightly, if above, it rises. Oxygen dissolves better in cold wine, so the wine must be protected from air. In energy terms the method is expensive: chilling 100 litres from 15 °C to −5 °C takes ≈ 2.1 kWh, without losses or holding.

Alternatives

Crystallisation inhibitors do not remove KHT: they attach to the crystal surface and prevent it from growing. The wine remains supersaturated, but crystals do not appear.

AgentDoseNotes
Metatartaric acid≤ 100 mg/Lcheap, immediate; hydrolyses: ≈ 3 months at 20 °C, over a year at 10–12 °C
Carboxymethylcellulose (CMC)≤ 100 mg/Ldurable; only in white and rosé, after protein stabilisation
Potassium polyaspartate (KPA)≤ 100 mg/Ldurable; in red as well
Mannoproteins200–300 mg/Lnatural; moderate effect
Electrodialysis—removes potassium and tartaric acid through a membrane; an industrial method

Cold stabilisation does not work against calcium tartrate; the only effective measures are avoiding sources of calcium and, if needed, inhibitors.

How to use this page

1. In the "Saturation and stability" mode enter the wine analysis: potassium, tartaric acid, pH and alcohol (for red, also the phenolics index if you know it; if not, leave 50). Choose the lowest temperature the wine may meet in bottle (a fridge is ≈ 4 °C). You will see the saturation temperature, the degree of supersaturation, how much KHT could precipitate, and a verdict by the Würdig criterion. The chart shows at what temperature the wine's CP meets the solubility curve.

2. The "Cold stabilisation" mode uses the same analysis. Choose the method, temperature and duration: you will see the wine's freezing point, the recommended temperature, how much KHT will precipitate in that time, how much the acidity will fall, and how much energy chilling will take.

3. In the "Alternatives" mode choose the additive, dose and wine volume: you get the grams, the duration of protection (for metatartaric acid, according to storage temperature) and whether it suits your wine.

You cannot measure potassium and tartaric acid at home: this is a laboratory analysis. If you have no analysis, use typical values: potassium 700–1200 mg/L (more in red and amber), tartaric acid 1.5–3.5 g/L.

A simple test at home

1. Pour wine into a clean, clear bottle and close it tightly.

2. Put it in the freezer at −4 to −6 °C (or in the coldest place in the fridge) for 3–6 days. The wine must not freeze: if ice crystals appear, raise the temperature.

3. Take the bottle out and, within 1–2 hours while it is still cold, look closely at the bottom against a torch. If fine, sparkling crystals can be seen, the wine is unstable.

4. The test is strict: if the wine passes it, it will also be stable in the fridge.

Practical tips

• If you will drink the wine soon, or it will always be kept in bottle in a cool (not cold) cellar, cold stabilisation is not essential.

• For cold stabilisation at home use a cold room in winter, a balcony or a second fridge. A large vessel cools slowly: check with a thermometer that the wine has really reached the target temperature.

• After holding cold, rack the wine while it is still cold, leaving the tartrate crust in the vessel. Remove the crust from the vessel walls with hot water and soda.

• Carry out cold stabilisation after protein stabilisation (bentonite): proteins hinder crystallisation, and bentonite lees settle better in the cold.

• Add metatartaric acid shortly before bottling; in warm storage it loses its strength quickly.

1. Fine, glass-like crystals have settled at the bottom of a bottle. What are they?

The potassium salt of tartaric acid is less soluble in the cold and crystallises. It is harmless and does not change the taste, but it often puts buyers off.

2. Why is red wine more stable against tartrate than a white wine of the same composition?

Tannins, anthocyanins and polysaccharides attach to the crystal surface and hinder its growth. That is why the Würdig criterion for red takes the phenolics index into account.

3. What temperature is usually recommended for cold stabilising a 12% wine?

The rule is −(A/2 − 1) °C, i.e. ≈ −5 °C for 12% wine, just above its freezing point (≈ −6 °C). At −15 °C the wine would freeze.