Winemaking Laboratory
Vinegar production / Acidity and starting material

Chapter X · Vinegar production

Acidity and starting material

Good vinegar starts with good wine: clean, sound, moderate in alcohol and free of SO₂. This page has three practical calculations: how to prepare wine for acetification, how to measure vinegar acidity by titration, and how to dilute or blend vinegar to the desired strength.

Wine

Mix = wine + water + live (unpasteurised) vinegar. Alcohol is usually 5–8% for the surface method and 8–12% for the submerged method. The wine's own acids are converted to acetic-acid equivalent (× 60/75). Expected acidity ≈ initial + alcohol × 1.03 × 0.92. Free SO₂ inhibits acetic acid bacteria, so it must be minimal in the mix (guide ≤ 10 mg/L, illustrative); the SO₂ of a sulphured wine decreases with aeration or time.

Water—L
Live vinegar—L
Mix—L
Expected acidity—%

Titration

Acidity (g/100 mL as acetic) = V·N·60.05 / (Vs·10). Vinegar is strong: a 2–5 mL sample is usually taken, diluted with 50 mL of water and titrated with 0.5 or 1 N NaOH to pH 8.2 (phenolphthalein). "Grain" is an American unit: 10 grain = 1%. The total acidity of wine vinegar also includes the wine's non-volatile acids (≈ 0.4–0.6%).

Acidity—%
g/L—g/L
Grain—grain
Molarity—mol/L

Vinegar

Blending rule (Pearson square): V₂ = V₁·(A₁ − A)/(A − A₂). The desired acidity must lie between the two components. Volume contraction is ignored (< 0.5%). Under the Codex standard, wine vinegar must have ≥ 6% (60 g/L) acidity and other vinegars ≥ 5%; keep these minima in mind when diluting.

To add—L
Final volume—L
Bottles (0.5 L)—
Check—

What wine is suitable for vinegar

Vinegar cannot improve the quality of a wine: the smell of a faulty wine (e.g. mouldy, with hydrogen sulphide or Brettanomyces) carries over into the vinegar. A wine that already has elevated volatile acidity, however, is perfectly usable for vinegar. The main requirements for the starting material are:

1. Alcohol: 5–8% for the surface method and 8–12% for the submerged method. Strong wine inhibits the bacteria, so it is diluted with water.
2. SO₂: free SO₂ inhibits acetic acid bacteria. Wine meant for vinegar should not be sulphured; in a sulphured wine SO₂ decreases with aeration, time or dilution.
3. Preservatives: sorbate, dimethyl dicarbonate and similar additives must be absent.
4. Nutrients: the bacteria need nitrogen and vitamins. Wine usually contains enough, but with heavy dilution the process may slow down.
5. Clarity: hazy, pectin-rich wine acetifies slowly and gives hazy vinegar; it is better to clarify it first.

Fruit vinegar is made from fruit wine (Chapter IX), for example apple vinegar from apple wine.

The starting mix

Live, unpasteurised vinegar is added to the fresh wine, usually 10–25%. This does two things: it introduces active bacteria and raises the acidity of the mix to 1–2% from the start, which suppresses other microorganisms (yeast film, lactic acid bacteria). Pasteurised shop vinegar is no good as an inoculum: its bacteria are dead.

The composition of the mix is calculated by mass balance. If the wine volume is $V_w$, its alcohol $a$, the desired alcohol in the mix $a_t$ and the share of live vinegar $f$, then:

$$V_{mix} = \frac{a\cdot V_w}{a_t},\qquad V_{inoc} = f\cdot V_{mix},\qquad V_{water} = V_{mix} - V_w - V_{inoc}$$

The wine's own (non-volatile) acids are also part of the acidity; to convert acidity expressed as tartaric acid to acetic acid, multiply by 60/75. The expected final acidity:

$$A \approx A_0 + a_{mix}\cdot 1.03\cdot\eta$$

where η ≈ 0.9 is the practical yield.

Measuring acidity

The total acidity of vinegar is measured by titration and expressed as acetic acid in g/100 mL (i.e. in %):

$$A\ [\%] = \frac{V_{NaOH}\cdot N\cdot 60.05}{V_s\cdot 10}$$

Vinegar is strong, so a 2–5 mL sample is taken, diluted with water and titrated with 0.5 or 1 N NaOH to pH 8.2. The OIV methods for vinegar distinguish:

• total acidity: all titratable acids;
• fixed acidity: the acids remaining after evaporation (tartaric, malic, etc.);
• volatile acidity: their difference, mainly acetic acid.

In American practice acidity is expressed in "grains": 10 grain = 1%, so 50-grain vinegar is 5%.

Because acetic acid dissociates only weakly, vinegar pH changes less than its acidity. For a weak acid:

$$\mathrm{pH} \approx \tfrac{1}{2}\left(pK_a - \log C\right),\qquad pK_a = 4.76$$

For 5% vinegar (C ≈ 0.83 mol/L), pH ≈ 2.4.

Dilution and blending

Dilution does not change the amount of acid, so blending two components is calculated with the "Pearson square":

$$V_2 = V_1\cdot\frac{A_1 - A}{A - A_2}$$

where $A_1$ and $A_2$ are the acidities of the components and A the desired one. For dilution with water, $A_2 = 0$. Use drinking-quality, chlorine-free water for dilution.

Under the Codex Alimentarius standard, the total acidity of wine vinegar is at least 60 g/L and that of other vinegars at least 50 g/L (as acetic acid). So vinegar to be sold as "wine vinegar" is not diluted below 6% (details in "Vinegar quality and law").

Sources

Codex Alimentarius, Regional Standard for Vinegar (CODEX STAN 162-1987); OIV, Resolution OIV-ECO 401-2012 "Wine vinegar"; OIV, Compendium of International Methods of Analysis for Vinegars (OIV-MA-VI-01, total acidity; fixed and volatile acidity); S. Tesfaye et al., Wine vinegar: technology, authenticity and quality evaluation (Trends Food Sci. Technol., 2002); L. Solieri, P. Giudici (eds.), Vinegars of the World (Springer, 2009). The SO₂ guide (≤ 10 mg/L in the mix) is illustrative.

How to use this page

1. In the "Starting material" mode, enter the wine volume, alcohol, acidity and free SO₂, the desired alcohol in the mix, the share of live vinegar and its acidity, to get the amounts of water and live vinegar, the volume of the mix and the expected acidity.

2. In the "Titration" mode, enter the NaOH volume used, its normality and the sample volume to get the acidity in %, g/L and grain, and the molarity. The chart compares your vinegar with the Codex minima and the typical acidity of submerged vinegar.

3. In the "Dilution and blending" mode, enter the vinegar volume and acidity, the acidity of the second component (0 for water) and the desired acidity to get the amount to add and the final volume.

Examples

• 20 L of 12% wine → 7% in the mix, 20% live 6% vinegar: ~7.4 L of water, ~6.9 L of vinegar, ~34 L of mix; expected acidity ~8%.

• 5 mL of vinegar, 8.5 mL of 0.5 N NaOH → 5.1% (51 g/L, 51 grain).

• 10 L of 9% vinegar → 6%: 5 L of water; or 15 L of 4% vinegar.

Practical tips

• Use only live, unpasteurised vinegar as an inoculum (or a "mother" from another cellar).

• Leave sulphured wine for a few days in an open, wide vessel or pour it over several times: the SO₂ will decrease.

• Before titration, dilute the vinegar sample at least 10 times with water: the colour change is easier to see.

• Measure acidity every week: when it stops rising, the alcohol has run out, so draw off the vinegar.

1. Why is heavily sulphured wine unsuitable for vinegar?

SO₂ is an antimicrobial and acts on bacteria too. Wine meant for vinegar should either be unsulphured or have its SO₂ reduced beforehand by aeration.

2. Titrating 5 mL of vinegar took 7 mL of 0.5 N NaOH. What is the acidity?

7 · 0.5 · 60.05 / (5 · 10) = 4.2 g/100 mL, i.e. 4.2% as acetic acid (42 grain).

3. How much water must be added to 10 L of 9% vinegar to make it 6%?

The amount of acid does not change: 10 · 9 = V · 6, V = 15 L. So 5 L of water.