Winemaking Laboratory
Vinegar production / Vinegar methods

Chapter X · Vinegar production

Vinegar methods

There are three main ways to make vinegar. The Orléans (surface) method is slow, taking weeks or months, and the bacteria get oxygen only from the liquid's surface. The trickling generator runs the liquid over beech shavings and multiplies the surface a thousandfold. The submerged acetator disperses air directly into the liquid and makes vinegar within a day.

Barrel or vessel

Illustrative model: the surface film makes ~240 g of acetic acid per day for each m² of liquid surface at 28 °C (with a temperature factor). The classic Orléans barrel (225 L) is filled to ~⅔, lies on its side and has a surface of ~0.5 m²; each week part of the vinegar is drawn off and the same amount of wine added without damaging the "mother". Air reaches the barrel through holes at the top.

Acetic acid production—g/day
Vinegar to draw per week—L
First batch—days
Depth—cm

Acetator

Semi-continuous cycle: when alcohol falls to ~0.2–0.3%, part of the vinegar (usually 40–50%) is drawn off and fresh wine added. The cycle time is calculated with the submerged-method model from the previous page (illustrative). Air flow comes from the oxygen demand at peak rate and the degree of oxygen utilisation; cooling from the heat of reaction (~493 kJ/mol). Interrupting aeration kills a high-acid culture.

Cycle—h
Output—L/day
Air (peak)—m³/h
Cooling (peak)—kW

Batch

The same starting material by three methods (with the illustrative kinetics from the previous page). The aroma assessment follows general conclusions in the literature: slow surface vinegar made in wood has a more complex aroma (ethyl acetate, acetoin, wood compounds), while fast submerged vinegar is "cleaner" and more neutral.

Surface—days
Generator—days
Submerged—days
Acidity—%

Oxygen, the main limit

Acetic acid bacteria need oxygen to oxidise ethanol, but oxygen dissolves poorly in water: at 30 °C only ~7 mg/L in equilibrium with air. Turning an 8% wine into vinegar needs ~44 g/L of oxygen, thousands of times more than the liquid can hold at once. So every vinegar method is essentially a way of supplying oxygen, and what mainly distinguishes them is how, and how fast, oxygen reaches the bacteria.

The Orléans (surface) method

This is the oldest method. The French city of Orléans became famous as a centre of the vinegar craft as early as the Middle Ages. Wine is put into an oak barrel that lies on its side and is filled to ~⅔; air moves through the barrel via holes in its upper part. A film of bacteria develops on the liquid's surface and takes oxygen from the surface.

Because oxygen enters only through the surface, production is proportional to the surface area, not to the volume:

$$P \approx k_s\cdot S\cdot f(T)$$

where P is acetic acid in g/day, S the liquid surface (m²), $k_s$ ≈ 240 g/m²·day (illustrative) and f(T) a temperature factor. That is why a large barrel works slowly with the Orléans method: the greater the depth, the more slowly the whole volume turns to vinegar.

In practice an Orléans barrel works semi-continuously: each week part of the vinegar (~8–10%) is drawn off through a bottom tap and the same amount of wine is added to the bottom through a funnel, so that the surface film is not damaged. One 225-litre barrel gives ~10–15 L of vinegar a week. The process is slow, but vinegar kept for a long time in wood acquires a soft, complex aroma.

The trickling generator

A "quick" method was developed in Germany in the early 19th century: a tall wooden vessel is filled with beech shavings, a wine-vinegar mixture is trickled in from the top, and air moves from the bottom upwards. A bacterial biofilm develops on the shavings, the liquid runs down in a thin layer, and the area of contact with air increases hundreds or thousands of times. The vinegar is ready within a few days; the mixture is passed through the generator several times. Forced aeration and cooling were later added to generators.

The submerged method (acetator)

The submerged method, developed in the mid-20th century, produces most industrial vinegar today. In an acetator a special turbine disperses air into the liquid as very fine bubbles, and the bacteria float freely in the liquid. The oxygen supply is very intensive, so a cycle lasts 24–36 hours.

The acetator works semi-continuously. When ethanol falls to ~0.2–0.3%, 40–50% of the vinegar is drawn off and fresh wine is added. The remaining vinegar is the "mother" of the new cycle: it keeps acidity high and makes the bacteria active from the start. The mass balance:

$$E_{mix} = (1-f)\,E_{res} + f\,E_{wine},\qquad A_{mix} = (1-f)\,A_{vinegar}$$

where f is the share drawn off. In submerged culture the bacteria depend entirely on oxygen: in a high-acid medium even a stop in aeration of a few minutes kills a large part of the culture. Because of the heat of reaction an acetator needs active cooling; a 1000-litre unit releases several kilowatts of heat at peak.

Submerged vinegar is clean and neutral, so quality wine vinegar is often aged afterwards in wooden barrels.

The "mother of vinegar"

The "mother of vinegar" is a slimy film that forms on the surface. It consists mainly of bacterial cellulose secreted by some acetic acid bacteria (especially Komagataeibacter xylinus) and contains the bacteria trapped in it. The "mother" is a sign of the surface method, but it does not itself make vinegar: the bacteria do that.

The "mother" is a convenient inoculum: a piece of it, or better, live unpasteurised vinegar, turns fresh wine into vinegar. However, a thick, heavy "mother" sinks to the bottom, where without oxygen the bacteria in it die; and the bacteria spend energy on making cellulose. That is why excess, sunken "mother" is removed.

Comparing the methods

MethodOxygen supplyTypical durationMax. acidityAroma
Orléansfrom the liquid's surfaceweeks–months~6–8%complex, soft
Generatorfrom the surface of the shavingsdays~10–12%medium
Submergedair bubbles in the liquid1–2 days12–15% and moreclean, neutral

The durations and acidity limits are typical and depend on the bacteria, temperature and equipment.

Sources

L. Pasteur, Études sur le vinaigre (1868); H. Ebner, S. Sellmer, H. Follmann, Acetic acid, in: Biotechnology, vol. 6 (Wiley-VCH); O. Hromatka, H. Ebner, Vinegar by submerged oxidative fermentation (Ind. Eng. Chem., 1959); S. Tesfaye et al., Wine vinegar: technology, authenticity and quality evaluation (Trends Food Sci. Technol., 2002); L. Solieri, P. Giudici (eds.), Vinegars of the World (Springer, 2009); M. Gullo, P. Giudici (2008). The surface rate of the Orléans method and the kinetic coefficients are illustrative.

How to use this page

1. In the "Orléans method" mode, enter the liquid volume and surface area, wine alcohol and temperature to get daily production, the amount of vinegar to draw each week, the duration of the first batch and the liquid depth. The chart shows how output grows with surface.

2. In the "Submerged acetator" mode, enter the working volume, the share drawn off, wine alcohol, alcohol at drawing, temperature and oxygen utilisation to get the cycle time, daily output, air flow and cooling power.

3. In the "Comparing methods" mode, the time to turn the same wine into vinegar is compared across the three methods.

Measuring the surface

• A barrel lying on its side: surface ≈ barrel length × width of the liquid surface. For a 225-litre barrel filled to ⅔ it is ≈ 0.5 m².
• A vertical cylinder or jar: S = π·d²/4, where d is the diameter.
• A wide open vessel (basin) gives the largest surface, but needs protection from dust and insects.

Examples

• 150 L in a barrel, 0.5 m², 7% wine, 27 °C → ~113 g of acetic acid per day, ~12 L of vinegar per week.

• 1000 L acetator, 45% drawn off, 10% wine, 30 °C → cycle ~28 h, ~380 L of 10% vinegar per day.

Practical tips

• At home the Orléans method is the simplest: a wide glass or ceramic vessel covered with gauze, and 20–30% live vinegar.

• Add wine to the vessel carefully, through a funnel to the bottom, so that the surface film is not broken.

• Remove a thick "mother" that has sunk: it is no longer useful.

• Do not use metal vessels (except stainless steel): vinegar dissolves them.

1. Why is an Orléans barrel filled only to ~⅔ and laid on its side?

In the surface method the bacteria get oxygen only from the liquid's surface. In a partly filled barrel lying on its side the surface is large and the depth small.

2. What determines the speed of a trickling generator?

A bacterial biofilm develops on the beech shavings, the liquid runs down in a thin layer and air moves upwards. The surface for oxygen transfer is multiplied many times.

3. What happens if aeration stops for a few minutes in a submerged acetator?

Bacteria in submerged culture depend entirely on oxygen. A shortage at high acidity quickly kills the cells, which is why acetators have a backup power supply.