Winemaking Laboratory
Vinegar production / Vinegar biochemistry and microbiology

Chapter X · Vinegar production

Vinegar biochemistry and microbiology

Vinegar is the product of a two-stage fermentation: first yeast turns sugar into ethanol, then acetic acid bacteria oxidise the ethanol to acetic acid with oxygen from the air. The second stage is an oxidation, not a fermentation: it needs a lot of oxygen, releases heat and is limited by the bacteria's sensitivity to acid and temperature.

From wine to vinegar

C₂H₅OH + O₂ → CH₃COOH + H₂O. 46.07 g of ethanol + 32.00 g of O₂ → 60.05 g of acetic acid: 1 g of ethanol theoretically gives 1.304 g of acid, and 1% vol of alcohol (7.89 g/L) gives 1.03% acidity (g/100 mL). The heat of reaction is ≈ 493 kJ per mole. Practical yield is 85–98% (evaporation, over-oxidation, biomass). The "total concentration", acidity (%) + alcohol (% vol), stays almost constant during acetification.

Final acidity—%
Oxygen—kg
Air (minimum)—m³
Heat—MJ

Process

Illustrative model: r = r_max·f(T)·E/(K_s+E)·1/(1+E/K_i)·(1−(A/A_max)³)·g(t), where E is ethanol, A is acetic acid (g/L) and g(t) is a lag phase that the inoculum shortens. r_max: surface 2.5, generator 20, submerged 60 g/L·day; A_max: 80, 110, 150 g/L. Optimum 28–30 °C; above 34 °C ordinary strains stop working. End point: ethanol < 0.3%.

Duration—days
Final acidity—%
Maximum rate—g/L
Status—

Conditions

The tolerance ranges are typical literature values (Acetobacter usually up to 6–8%, Komagataeibacter up to 10–20%). The over-oxidation rate is illustrative: once ethanol runs out, Acetobacter oxidises acetic acid to CO₂ and water, which is why a little ethanol (0.2–0.5%) is left in production.

Dominant bacteria—
Acid lost to over-oxidation—%
Remaining acidity—%
Risk—

Two stages

Vinegar is the result of two biological processes:

1. Alcoholic fermentation: yeast anaerobically converts sugar into ethanol and CO₂ (see Chapter III).
2. Acetification: acetic acid bacteria oxidise ethanol to acetic acid with oxygen.

The second stage is strictly aerobic. Biochemically it is an oxidation, not a fermentation, although it is traditionally called "acetic fermentation". In the 1860s Louis Pasteur showed that the conversion of wine into vinegar is caused by living microorganisms, which he called Mycoderma aceti.

Stoichiometry

The overall reaction:

$$\mathrm{C_2H_5OH + O_2 \rightarrow CH_3COOH + H_2O},\qquad \Delta H \approx -493\ \text{kJ/mol}$$

46.07 g of ethanol gives 60.05 g of acetic acid, i.e. the theoretical yield is 1.304 g/g. 1% vol of alcohol is 7.89 g/L of ethanol, so:

$$1\%\ \text{vol alcohol} \rightarrow 7.89\cdot 1.304 = 10.3\ \text{g/L} \approx 1.03\%\ \text{acidity}$$

The practical yield is 85–98%: part of the ethanol and acid evaporates, and part is spent on biomass growth and over-oxidation.

Vinegar production uses the "total concentration": the sum of acidity (%) and alcohol (% vol). Since 1% of alcohol becomes ~1% of acid, this value stays almost constant during acetification and is a simple way to check the yield: if it falls, acid or alcohol is being lost.

Oxygen and heat

Oxidising 1 g of ethanol needs 0.695 g of O₂. For 100 L of 8% wine that is ~4 kg of oxygen, or ~15 m³ of air, a theoretical minimum; in reality only part of the oxygen in the air is absorbed. In the surface method oxygen diffuses from the liquid's surface, so the process is slow; in the submerged method air is dispersed into the liquid as small bubbles.

The reaction is exothermic: oxidising 1 kg of ethanol releases ~10.7 MJ of heat. In a slow process this heat goes unnoticed, but a submerged acetator needs active cooling.

Biochemistry

Acetic acid bacteria oxidise ethanol without taking it into the cell, in the periplasmic space. Two enzymes of the cytoplasmic membrane do this:

1. PQQ-dependent alcohol dehydrogenase: ethanol → acetaldehyde;
2. aldehyde dehydrogenase: acetaldehyde → acetic acid.

The electrons pass directly to the respiratory chain and to oxygen. This "incomplete oxidation" gives the bacterium little energy but is very fast, which is exactly why large amounts of acetic acid accumulate in the medium.

Acetaldehyde is an intermediate. If oxygen is short, it accumulates and gives the vinegar a sharp, "apple-like" smell.

Bacteria

Three genera dominate vinegar production:

• Gluconobacter prefers sugars (oxidises glucose to gluconic acid), is relatively acid-sensitive and is found at the start of acetification or in sweet media;
• Acetobacter (A. aceti, A. pasteurianus) is the main microorganism of traditional surface vinegar; it usually stops working at 6–8% acidity;
• Komagataeibacter (K. europaeus, K. oboediens; formerly Gluconacetobacter) tolerates up to 10–20% acidity and is the main producer of high-acid vinegar by the submerged method; K. xylinus forms bacterial cellulose, the "mother of vinegar".

The optimum temperature for most of these bacteria is 25–30 °C; above 34 °C ordinary strains no longer grow, although thermotolerant strains are known. High ethanol (> 10–12%) inhibits the bacteria, so the starting material is usually diluted to 5–10% alcohol.

In submerged culture the bacteria are very sensitive to interruption of oxygen: in a high-acid medium even a short stop in aeration can kill a large part of the culture.

Kinetics

The calculator's model combines the typical factors:

$$r = r_{max}\cdot f(T)\cdot\frac{E}{K_s+E}\cdot\frac{1}{1+E/K_i}\cdot\left[1-\left(\frac{A}{A_{max}}\right)^3\right]\cdot g(t)$$

where E is ethanol, A acetic acid, $K_s$ the half-saturation constant, $K_i$ the ethanol inhibition constant, $A_{max}$ the acidity at which the bacteria stop and g(t) the lag phase. Adding old vinegar or "mother" raises acidity from the start (which suppresses foreign microflora) and shortens the lag phase. The model's coefficients are illustrative.

Over-oxidation

Acetobacter has a complete tricarboxylic acid cycle: when ethanol runs out, it oxidises acetic acid to CO₂ and water. Acidity falls, the vinegar becomes "empty" and spoils easily. That is why:

• acetification is stopped when ethanol falls to 0.2–0.5%;
• in continuous and semi-continuous processes part of the vinegar is drawn off and fresh wine is added;
• finished vinegar is protected from air, filtered or pasteurised.

High-acid Komagataeibacter strains over-oxidise much less.

Sources

L. Pasteur, Études sur le vinaigre (1868); M. Gullo, P. Giudici, Acetic acid bacteria in traditional balsamic vinegar (Int. J. Food Microbiol., 2008); D. Mamlouk, M. Gullo, Acetic acid bacteria: physiology and carbon sources oxidation (Indian J. Microbiol., 2013); N. N. Y. Hata et al., Role of acetic acid bacteria in food and beverages (Food Technol. Biotechnol., 2023); C. Andrés-Barrao et al., bacteria in high-acid spirit vinegar (Univ. Neuchâtel); J. J. Román-Camacho et al., Komagataeibacter europaeus (Front. Microbiol., 2022); H. Ebner, S. Sellmer, H. Follmann, Acetic acid, in: Biotechnology, vol. 6 (Wiley-VCH). The kinetic and over-oxidation coefficients are illustrative.

How to use this page

1. In the "Stoichiometry" mode, enter the wine volume and alcohol, the initial acidity (if you added old vinegar), residual alcohol and yield to get the final acidity, the minimum amounts of oxygen and air, and the heat released.

2. In the "Acetification kinetics" mode, choose the method, alcohol, inoculum (old vinegar) share and temperature: the chart shows ethanol falling and acidity rising, and the cards show the duration and status of the process.

3. In the "Bacteria and over-oxidation" mode, enter the acidity, residual ethanol, temperature and days since ethanol ran out to get the dominant bacteria and the acidity lost.

Examples

• 100 L of wine, 8%, initial acidity 1%, yield 92% → ~8.3% vinegar; ~4.2 kg of oxygen (~16 m³ of air), ~65 MJ of heat.

• Surface method, 8% alcohol, 20% old vinegar, 28 °C → ~2 months; by the submerged method, ~2 days.

• 7% vinegar without ethanol, 14 days at 28 °C → ~0.5% acidity lost to over-oxidation.

Practical tips

• Dilute the starting wine to 6–9% alcohol: strong wine inhibits the bacteria.

• Add 10–25% live, unpasteurised vinegar: it raises acidity, protects against foreign microflora and speeds up the process.

• Keep the temperature at 25–30 °C; above 34 °C the bacteria are damaged.

• At the end of acetification, draw off the vinegar promptly and leave a little ethanol so that over-oxidation does not start.

1. How much acidity does an 8% vol wine give on complete acetification (in theory)?

1% vol of alcohol is 7.89 g/L of ethanol, which gives 1.304 times as much, i.e. 10.3 g/L of acetic acid, or 1.03%. An 8% wine gives ~8.2% vinegar; in practice slightly less.

2. Why is it dangerous to continue acetification after the ethanol has run out?

Acetobacter has a complete tricarboxylic acid cycle and consumes acetic acid as well when there is no ethanol. That is why 0.2–0.5% ethanol is left in production and the vinegar is drawn off promptly.

3. Which bacteria survive in 15% vinegar?

Komagataeibacter strains tolerate up to 10–20% acidity and are the main producers of high-acid vinegar by the submerged method; Acetobacter usually stops at 6–8%.