Winemaking Laboratory
History, Culture and Legislation / Archaeology: 8,000 years

Chapter VIII · History and culture

Archaeology: 8,000 years

In Kvemo Kartli, chemical traces of wine in Neolithic pottery from Shulaveris Gora and Gadachrili Gora date to 6000–5800 BC: the oldest biomolecular evidence of grape wine in the world. How this was established, how radiocarbon dating works, and where this discovery stands in the history of wine.

Event

The timeline axis is logarithmic (years before present) so that both domestication 11,000 years ago and events of the 21st century fit on one chart. Dates are calibrated dates as given in the sources; events marked "by tradition" rest on historical tradition.

When—
Where—
How long ago—years
What happened—

Sample

A living organism is in ¹⁴C equilibrium with the atmosphere; after death ¹⁴C decays. The conventional radiocarbon age (BP, from 1950) is calculated with the Libby half-life (5568 years): t = −8033·ln F. The accurate half-life is 5730 years (t = −8267·ln F). The ¹⁴C content of the atmosphere has varied over time, so a real (calendar) date requires calibration against the IntCal20 curve (OxCal, CALIB); this calculator cannot calibrate. For an age of ~7000 BP the calibrated date is roughly 800 years older.

Radiocarbon age—years
Uncalibrated date—
Age with T½ = 5730 years—years
¹⁴C remaining—

The cradle of wine

The South Caucasus holds a special place in the history of the vine and wine. Here the wild grapevine (Vitis vinifera subsp. sylvestris) still grows in forests and river valleys, and more than 500 local varieties are recorded in Georgia. This diversity points to a long local domestication and cross-breeding of the vine.

Neolithic wine: Gadachrili Gora and Shulaveris Gora

In Kvemo Kartli, ≈ 50 km south of Tbilisi in the Khrami valley, lie the remains of two Neolithic villages, Gadachrili Gora and Shulaveris Gora. They belong to the Shulaveri-Shomutepe culture, dated to ≈ 5900–5000 BC, which extended into Azerbaijan and the Armenian highlands. The inhabitants lived in round mud-brick houses, farmed, raised domestic animals and were among the first to make pottery.

Excavations in 2012–2016 and the re-study of old collections (a Georgian–Canadian expedition of the Georgian National Museum and the University of Toronto) recovered organic residues from the inner surfaces of potsherds. The analysis was carried out at the University of Pennsylvania Museum under Patrick McGovern. In 2017 the result was published in PNAS: residues from eight large jars contained tartaric acid with associated malic, succinic and citric acids. This is the world's oldest biomolecular evidence of grape wine, ≈ 6000–5800 BC.

The discovery rests on several independent lines of evidence:

1. Chemical: tartaric acid, which in the Near East occurs in large amounts only in grapes and wine, was identified by liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry (LC-MS-MS), and control samples (soil, outer surfaces of the jars) contained much less.

2. Botanical: high levels of grape pollen and grape remains in the soil; climate reconstruction shows conditions for the vine similar to modern Italy and southern France.

3. Archaeological: large, wide-mouthed jars, some up to ≈ 300 litres, with relief decorations of grape clusters, similar in shape to the modern qvevri.

4. Chronological: many radiocarbon dates from well-defined layers.

Notably, no resin was found in the residues: this may be the oldest example of "pure" wine without resin.

Domestication of the grapevine

In 2023 Science published an analysis of the genomes of 3,525 wild and cultivated vines (Dong et al.). The study showed that the vine was domesticated ≈ 11,000 years ago concurrently in two centres, Western Asia and the Caucasus, at the beginning of agriculture. Vines from the Western Asian centre spread to Europe with the first farmers and crossed with local wild vines; the Caucasian centre is linked to one of the ancestries of the wine grapevine.

Other ancient evidence

SiteDateEvidence
Gadachrili Gora, Shulaveris Gora (Georgia)6000–5800 BCtartaric acid in jars, grape pollen
Hajji Firuz Tepe (Iran)5400–5000 BCtartaric acid and resin in jars
Areni-1 (Armenia)≈ 4000 BCpressing installation, jars, grape remains in a cave

Radiocarbon dating

The radioactive carbon isotope ¹⁴C is continuously produced in the atmosphere by cosmic rays and enters every living organism through photosynthesis. After death no new ¹⁴C enters, and the existing ¹⁴C decays:

$$N(t) = N_0\,e^{-\lambda t}, \qquad t = -\frac{1}{\lambda}\ln F = -\frac{T_{1/2}}{\ln 2}\ln F,$$

where $F = N/N_0$ is the fraction of modern carbon. By convention, the conventional radiocarbon age is calculated with the Libby half-life ($T_{1/2} = 5568$ years, $1/\lambda = 8033$ years) and measured from 1950 (BP). The accurate half-life is 5730 years.

The ¹⁴C content of the atmosphere has changed over time, so radiocarbon years do not match calendar years. To obtain a real date, a calibration curve (IntCal20) is used, built from measurements of tree rings and other precisely dated samples. A sample with a radiocarbon age of ≈ 7000 years has a calendar age of about 7800–7900 years; this is how the "8,000 years" of the Neolithic wine is obtained.

Sources

P. McGovern, M. Jalabadze, S. Batiuk et al., "Early Neolithic wine of Georgia in the South Caucasus", PNAS 114 (48), E10309–E10318 (2017), doi:10.1073/pnas.1714728114; Y. Dong et al., "Dual domestications and origin of traits in grapevine evolution", Science 379, 892–901 (2023), doi:10.1126/science.add8655; P. McGovern et al., "Neolithic resinated wine", Nature 381 (1996); H. Barnard et al., "Chemical evidence for wine production around 4000 BCE in the Late Chalcolithic Near Eastern highlands", J. Archaeol. Sci. 38 (2011); P. J. Reimer et al., "The IntCal20 Northern Hemisphere radiocarbon age calibration curve", Radiocarbon 62 (2020).

How to use this page

1. In the "Timeline" mode, choose an event from the list or click a point on the chart. The cards show the date, place, how long ago it happened and a short description with its source. The axis is logarithmic: millennia on the left, recent decades on the right.

2. In the "Radiocarbon dating" mode, enter the fraction of ¹⁴C remaining in the sample (F, relative to modern carbon) and the measurement error. You will see the conventional radiocarbon age with its error, the uncalibrated date, the physical age with the 5730-year half-life, and the number of half-lives elapsed. The chart also shows where a Neolithic wine sample sits.

Try this

• F = 0.5: exactly one half-life (5568 radiocarbon years).

• F = 0.418: about the age of the Gadachrili Gora samples (≈ 7000 radiocarbon years, ≈ 7900 years after calibration).

• Increase the error and see how the age uncertainty grows, especially for old samples, since $\sigma_t = 8033\,\sigma_F / F$.

Important

This calculator cannot calibrate. For scientific dating use OxCal or CALIB with the IntCal20 curve.

Worth seeing

Neolithic pottery and the history of the qvevri are in the archaeological exhibition of the Georgian National Museum (Tbilisi). Archaeological sites near Shulaveri in Kvemo Kartli are still being studied.

1. The detection of which compound confirmed wine in the Neolithic pottery?

Ethanol is volatile and cannot survive for millennia. Tartaric acid, however, occurs in large amounts in the Near East only in grapes and wine. It was found in the walls of the jars together with malic, succinic and citric acids.

2. Why does a radiocarbon date need calibration?

Changes in solar activity, the Earth's magnetic field and the ocean altered atmospheric ¹⁴C levels. The calibration curve (IntCal20) is built from measurements of tree rings and other precisely dated samples.

3. What does the 2023 genomic study show about grapevine domestication?

Analysis of 3,525 wild and cultivated vine genomes showed two concurrent domestications at the beginning of agriculture. The Caucasian centre is linked to one of the ancestries of the wine grapevine.