Winemaking Laboratory
Fruit wines / Fruit acids

Chapter IX · Fruit wines

Fruit acids

The acidity of grapes comes from tartaric and malic acid; that of other fruits mostly from malic and citric acid, sometimes also isocitric and quinic acid. The type of acid determines the taste, the pH, bacterial risks and how acidity can be changed: because there is little tartaric acid, many methods proven in grape wine work differently in fruit wine.

Fruit

Acid shares by equivalents, illustrative, using typical literature values; they vary a lot with variety (e.g. in pomegranate, malic acid dominates in sweet varieties and citric in sour ones). In malolactic fermentation every 2 equivalents of malic acid become 1 equivalent of lactic acid, so acidity falls by half of the malic share.

Dominant acid—
Malic acid—%
Citric acid—%
Acidity after malolactic fermentation—g/L

Titration

TA = V·N·E / Vs, where E is the equivalent mass of the acid: tartaric 75, malic 67, anhydrous citric 64, sulphuric 49 g/eq. Titration is carried out to pH 8.2 (phenolphthalein) or pH 7.0 (European practice); the results differ by ~5%. For fruit wine, titration with a pH meter is recommended: dark juice colour masks the indicator's colour change.

As tartaric—g/L
As malic—g/L
As citric—g/L
In equivalents—meq/L

Changing acidity

Chemical doses are theoretical: 1 g of KHCO₃ = 0.75 g and 1 g of CaCO₃ = 1.50 g of tartaric-acid equivalent. In grape wine tartrate also precipitates, but fruit wine has little tartaric acid: potassium and calcium malates and citrates are soluble and stay in the wine (salty taste, risk of later calcium precipitation). Chemical deacidification is usually limited to 1.5–2 g/L. The pH change is estimated with the buffer capacity: ΔpH ≈ Δmeq / β.

Needed—
Recommended method—
Dose—
New pH (estimate)—

Fruit acids

Fruit acids are weak organic acids with one, two or three carboxyl groups per molecule. Their strength is expressed by the dissociation constant (pKa): the lower the pKa, the stronger the acid and the more it lowers the pH at the same concentration.

AcidCarboxylspKaEq. mass, g/eqWhere it dominatesTaste
Tartaric22.98; 4.3475grapessharp, "hard"
Malic23.40; 5.1167apple, sour cherry, cherry plum, cornelian cherrygreen apple, lingering
Citric33.13; 4.76; 6.4064raspberry, blackcurrant, pomegranateclean, "lively", short
Isocitric33.29; 4.71; 6.4064blackberrysimilar to citric
Quinic13.46192plum, quince, pearsoft, slightly bitter
Lactic13.8690formed during fermentationsoft

Tartaric acid is the strongest and is hardly broken down by bacteria, which is exactly why grape wine is microbiologically stable. Most fruits contain almost none. The shares of fruit acids (by equivalents) are in the calculator's first mode; they are illustrative and vary a lot with variety.

Titratable acidity and pH

Titratable acidity is the sum of all titratable hydrogen ions, both dissociated and undissociated. It is measured by titration:

$$TA = \frac{V_{NaOH}\cdot N\cdot E}{V_s}$$

where $V_{NaOH}$ is the volume of alkali used (mL), N its normality, E the equivalent mass of the acid in which the result is expressed (75 for tartaric acid) and $V_s$ the sample volume (mL). The result is in g/L. The same acidity is expressed by different numbers for different acids: 6.0 g/L as tartaric = 5.36 g/L as malic = 80 meq/L.

The pH, on the other hand, is the concentration of free hydrogen ions and depends on the strength of the acids, their amount and the content of salts (above all potassium). So two wines with the same acidity can have different pH. Fruit is often rich in potassium, so the pH of fruit wine can be high even when acidity is high.

Buffer capacity

Wine is a buffer solution: acid or alkali changes its pH less than in water. The buffer capacity β shows how many meq/L of alkali or acid are needed to change the pH by one unit. For small changes:

$$\Delta\mathrm{pH} \approx \frac{\Delta TA\ [\text{meq/L}]}{\beta}$$

β depends on the wine's acid content and pH; in the calculator it is an input parameter. For an exact forecast it is better to run a bench trial: add the dose to 100 mL of wine and measure the pH.

Reducing acidity

1. Dilution with water or blending with a less acidic fruit is the simplest way, but it reduces aroma and extract (see "Preparing fruit must").

2. Malolactic fermentation: lactic acid bacteria (Oenococcus oeni) convert malic acid into lactic acid and CO₂. A diprotic acid becomes a monoprotic one, so acidity falls by half of the malic-acid equivalents:

$$\Delta TA = \frac{TA\cdot x_{mal}}{2}$$

where $x_{mal}$ is the share of malic acid. This method is effective in apple, sour cherry, cherry plum and cornelian cherry wine. In fruit rich in citric acid (raspberry, blackcurrant), however, bacteria break down citric acid and produce diacetyl (buttery smell) and acetic acid.

3. Chemical deacidification. Potassium bicarbonate (KHCO₃) and calcium carbonate (CaCO₃) neutralise acid: in theory 1 g of KHCO₃ removes 0.75 g and 1 g of CaCO₃ 1.50 g of tartaric-acid equivalent. In grape wine the tartrates formed precipitate and leave the wine. Fruit wine has almost no tartaric acid, and malates and citrates are soluble, so the salt stays in the wine, makes it taste salty, and the calcium may precipitate later. That is why chemical deacidification of fruit wine is limited to 1.5–2 g/L.

4. Biological deacidification with yeast. The yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe converts malic acid into ethanol (the so-called malo-ethanolic fermentation); some Saccharomyces strains also consume 20–40% of the malic acid. This method does not affect citric acid.

Raising acidity

Low-acid fruit (persimmon, mulberry, pear) needs added acid, above all to lower the pH so that SO₂ works effectively and bacteria do not develop. Tartaric acid is the strongest and is stable against bacteria, but in potassium-rich wine part of it precipitates as tartrate, so cold stabilisation afterwards is advisable. Malic acid is soft but can be broken down by malolactic fermentation. Citric acid "brightens" fruit aroma but is bacterially unstable; in grape wine the EU limits its final content to 1 g/L. Acid is always added in portions, after a bench trial.

Sources

P. Ribéreau-Gayon et al., Handbook of Enology, vols. 1–2 (Wiley); R. S. Jackson, Wine Science (Academic Press); Y. Margalit, Concepts in Wine Chemistry (Wine Appreciation Guild); H. Volschenk, H. J. J. van Vuuren, M. Viljoen-Bloom, Malic acid in wine: origin, function and metabolism during vinification (S. Afr. J. Enol. Vitic., 2006); OIV, Compendium of International Methods of Analysis, Total acidity (OIV-MA-AS313-01); A. C. Hulme (ed.), The Biochemistry of Fruits and their Products. The shares of fruit acids and the buffer capacity value are illustrative.

How to use this page

1. In the "Acid profile" mode, choose a fruit and enter its acidity: the cards show the dominant acid, the shares of malic and citric acid and how much acidity will fall after malolactic fermentation. The chart compares the acid composition of all fruits; your fruit is outlined.

2. In the "Titration and conversion" mode, enter the NaOH volume used, its normality and the sample volume to get the acidity as tartaric, malic and citric acid and in equivalents.

3. In the "Adjusting acidity" mode, choose a fruit and enter the current and desired acidity, pH, buffer capacity and volume: the calculator recommends a method, works out the dose and estimates the new pH. The chart shows how much each method can reduce acidity within practical limits.

Examples

• 10 mL of wine, 8 mL of 0.1 N NaOH → 6.0 g/L as tartaric, 5.36 g/L as malic, 80 meq/L.

• Apple wine, 9 → 7 g/L: malic acid dominates, so malolactic fermentation is enough; the pH will rise by about 0.3 units (at β = 90 meq/L·pH).

• Quince wine, 13 → 7 g/L: chemical deacidification alone is not enough; dilution or blending with a less acidic fruit is needed.

Practical tips

• In dark wine, find the titration end point with a pH meter (pH 8.2): the phenolphthalein colour change is not visible against a dark background.

• For chemical deacidification, first run a trial on 100 mL of wine and taste it: a salty taste can be noticeable even at small doses.

• To avoid malolactic fermentation in wine rich in citric acid, keep enough SO₂ and a low temperature.

• After adding acid, measure the pH: the target for fruit wine is usually 3.2–3.6.

1. Why does deacidification with calcium carbonate not work in apple wine the way it does in grape wine?

In grape wine the added calcium precipitates as calcium tartrate and leaves the wine. Apple wine has no tartrate, so the salt remains in solution, changes the taste and may precipitate later.

2. About 85% of the acids in blackcurrant are citric acid. What will malolactic fermentation do?

Lactic acid bacteria turn malic acid into lactic acid, and blackcurrant has little of it. Citric acid, however, is broken down by some strains, giving a buttery smell and volatile acidity.

3. Titrating 10 mL of wine took 8 mL of 0.1 N NaOH. What is the acidity as tartaric acid?

TA = 8 · 0.1 · 75 / 10 = 6.0 g/L. Expressed as malic acid, the same acidity is 5.4 g/L.