Winemaking Laboratory
Alcoholic fermentation / Malolactic fermentation

Chapter III · Alcoholic fermentation

Malolactic fermentation

How lactic acid bacteria turn sharp malic acid into soft lactic acid: under what conditions this fermentation starts, how long it takes in a qvevri or tank, and how the acidity and pH of the wine change.

Wine parameters

Factors on a 0–1 scale: 1 is optimal for the bacteria, 0 is full inhibition. Overall suitability is their product. The model is based on literature limits for Oenococcus oeni and is illustrative: strains differ widely.

Overall suitability—%
Molecular SO₂—mg/L
Main limiting factor—
Spontaneous start—

Fermentation conditions

O. oeni growth: dX/dt = μ·f·X(1 − X/Xmax) − kd·X; malic acid is consumed with Michaelis-Menten kinetics, in proportion to the bacterial population. Completion: malic acid ≤ 0.1 g/L (no spot visible on paper chromatography). The Rf values of the chromatogram are approximate (butanol / formic acid / water).

Active start—
Completion—
Peak bacteria—CFU/mL
Malic acid left—g/L

Wine acids

Reaction: malic acid → lactic acid + CO₂ (134.09 → 90.08 + 44.01 g). pH is computed from the charge balance with Davies activity coefficients (see "Acids and pH"); other cations 6 meq/L, phosphate 2 mmol/L. The effect of ethanol on pKa is ignored. Total acidity as tartaric, to pH 7.0.

pH—
Total acidity—g/L
Lactic acid formed—g/L
CO₂ released—g/L

Intuition

After alcoholic fermentation a second, quiet fermentation often starts in the wine. It is carried out not by yeast but by lactic acid bacteria: they convert malic acid, the sharp acid of green apples, into lactic acid and carbon dioxide. The wine becomes less acidic, softer and fuller, its colour and aroma change, and, most importantly, it becomes biologically stable: the malic acid on which bacteria could grow in the bottle is gone.

In traditional Kakhetian wine the qvevri "takes care" of this fermentation by itself: the wine stays on the pomace for a long time, there is little or no SO₂, and the bacteria finish the job in autumn or in spring as it warms up. This page calculates under what conditions malolactic fermentation starts, how long it takes, and how much the acidity and pH change.

History

Winemakers have long known that in spring the wine "ferments again" and softens. In the 1890s the Swiss Hermann Müller-Thurgau linked this phenomenon to bacteria, and in 1913 he and Adolf Osterwalder described bacterial deacidification systematically. In the mid-20th century Émile Peynaud and Jean Ribéreau-Gayon in Bordeaux showed that this fermentation is essential for the quality of red wine.

Paper chromatography, the most accessible way to monitor the fermentation, came into use in the 1950s. In 1967 the main bacterium was described as Leuconostoc oenos; since 1995 it has been called Oenococcus oeni. From the 1980s–90s freeze-dried (lyophilised) bacterial cultures for direct addition to wine became available.

The reaction

The bacterium's malolactic enzyme converts L-malic acid directly into L-lactic acid and CO₂:

$$\text{HOOC–CH}_2\text{–CHOH–COOH} \rightarrow \text{CH}_3\text{–CHOH–COOH} + \text{CO}_2$$

By mass: 134.09 g of malic acid → 90.08 g of lactic acid + 44.01 g of CO₂. So 1 g/L of malic acid gives 0.67 g/L of lactic acid and 0.33 g/L of CO₂.

For the bacterium this is a source of energy: exporting a proton from the cell creates a potential across the membrane that is used to make ATP. That is why the bacterium breaks down malic acid even when it is hardly growing.

Acidity and pH

Malic acid is diprotic (pKa 3.40 and 5.20); lactic acid is monoprotic and weaker (pKa 3.86). The conversion therefore lowers titratable acidity:

$$\Delta TA = m_{\text{mal}}\left(\frac{2\cdot 75.04}{134.09} - \frac{0.6718\cdot 75.04}{90.08}\right) \approx 0.56\,m_{\text{mal}}$$

(as tartaric, g/L). 3 g/L of malic acid lowers total acidity by ≈ 1.7 g/L. The pH usually rises by 0.1–0.3: the more malic acid and the lower the buffer capacity, the larger the rise. The calculator computes pH from the charge balance, as on the "Acids and pH" page.

The bacteria

In wine malolactic fermentation is mainly carried out by Oenococcus oeni, the only bacterium that tolerates low pH, alcohol and SO₂ at the same time. At high pH (> 3.5) species of Lactobacillus and Pediococcus also become active, often bringing unwanted by-products: biogenic amines (histamine), volatile acidity, "mousy" taint, and "ropy" (oily, slimy) wine.

Bacterial growth depends on four factors:

FactorOptimumDifficultPractically impossible
pH> 3.33.1–3.2< 3.0
Alcohol< 13%14–15%> 15.5%
Temperature20–25 °C12–16 °C< 10 °C
Molecular SO₂00.1–0.3 mg/L> 0.5 mg/L
Bound SO₂< 30 mg/L40–60 mg/L> 80 mg/L

The factors reinforce each other: at pH 3.2, 14% alcohol and 15 °C each one alone is "possible", but together they almost are not.

Kinetic model

The calculator follows the bacterial population $X$ (CFU/mL) and malic acid $M$ (g/L):

$$\frac{dX}{dt} = \mu_{\max} f\,X\left(1 - \frac{X}{X_{\max}}\right) - k_d X$$

$$\frac{dM}{dt} = -q\,a\,X\,\frac{M}{M + K_m}$$

where $f = f_{pH} f_E f_{SO_2} f_T$ is the product of the factors, $\mu_{\max} = 0.7$ day⁻¹, $X_{\max} = 5\cdot10^7$ CFU/mL, $K_m = 0.3$ g/L. The death rate $k_d$ rises steeply with chemical stress (pH, alcohol, SO₂); cold slows growth but does not kill the bacteria. The temperature factor uses the cardinal temperature model (CTMI: 8 / 25 / 36 °C).

Active fermentation needs ≈ 10⁶ CFU/mL. After alcoholic fermentation the indigenous bacteria in wine are usually at 10²–10⁴ CFU/mL, so spontaneous fermentation has a "lag" of several weeks. Adding a culture (10⁶–10⁷ CFU/mL) skips this stage.

The model parameters are fitted to literature ranges and are illustrative: strains, nutrients and the yeast strain change the result strongly.

Paper chromatography

A simple and cheap method: drops of wine are spotted on chromatography paper together with standards (tartaric, malic and lactic acid), and the paper is stood in a solvent of butanol, formic acid, water and the indicator bromocresol green. The solvent climbs up the paper and carries the acids different distances. After drying the background turns blue-green and the acids show as yellow spots.

The position of a spot is expressed as $R_f$: its distance from the start divided by the distance of the solvent front. Approximately: tartaric 0.28, citric 0.42, malic 0.51, lactic 0.69 (succinic acid runs close to lactic, so a small spot at that height can be present even before the fermentation). The fermentation is considered complete when the malic acid spot is no longer visible, which corresponds to ≈ 0.1–0.2 g/L. For precise control, enzymatic analysis is used.

Taste and aroma

O. oeni also breaks down citric acid and in doing so produces diacetyl, the aroma of butter. In small amounts (1–4 mg/L) it adds complexity; in larger amounts it makes the wine buttery. More diacetyl is formed when the bacteria work slowly and in contact with oxygen; live yeast and lees reduce it.

The wine loses its green, sharp acidity, the colour drops slightly (with higher pH the anthocyanins are less red), and the tannins soften. In aromatic white wines (e.g. Rkatsiteli or Mtsvane made in the European way) malolactic fermentation is often avoided to keep freshness.

When it is not wanted

• In semi-sweet and sweet wine: the bacteria also use the residual sugar and produce acetic acid, D-lactic acid and off-odours.

• In very soft, high-pH wine: further loss of acidity makes the wine "flat" and raises the microbiological risk.

• In fresh, aromatic white wines: depending on the style.

To avoid malolactic fermentation the wine is protected with SO₂ right after alcoholic fermentation (free 30–40 mg/L), kept cold and racked off the lees early; for full certainty, sterile filtration.

Do you want malolactic fermentation

Desirable: in red wine (almost always), in amber wine made the Kakhetian way, in high-acid wine (malic acid > 2 g/L), and in any wine that is to be kept with minimal or no SO₂: an unfinished malolactic fermentation will start in the bottle.

Not desirable: in semi-sweet and sweet wine; in fresh, aromatic white wine; in wine whose pH is already above 3.6.

Step by step: carrying out malolactic fermentation

1. Check the conditions in the first mode of the calculator: pH, alcohol, SO₂, temperature. If overall suitability is below 25%, first change the main limiting factor (most often temperature).

2. Do not add SO₂ at the end of alcoholic fermentation. If the must was sulphited, total SO₂ should be below 30–40 mg/L.

3. Keep it warm: 18–22 °C. Move a tank or glass (or plastic) vessel into a warm room. In a qvevri the wine is still warm in autumn, and that is the best time.

4. Lees: the fine yeast lees feed the bacteria. Do the first racking (off the gross lees), leave the fine lees and stir gently once a week.

5. Optional: a culture: add a purchased O. oeni culture following its instructions (usually at the end of or after alcoholic fermentation). This speeds the fermentation up and makes it predictable. Co-inoculation (24–48 hours after the yeast) is faster still, but needs compatible strains.

6. Monitor: paper chromatography every 1–2 weeks. Signs: fine bubbles at the surface, slight haze, less acidity on the palate.

7. When finished: once the malic acid spot has gone, rack the wine off the lees and add SO₂ immediately (free 25–35 mg/L depending on pH; dose calculation on the "Must preparation" page). Keep the wine cool.

Qvevri in winter

In a qvevri buried in the ground the wine temperature falls slowly from 16–18 °C in autumn to 10–12 °C in winter (less in a deep cellar). In the second mode of the calculator choose "Qvevri in winter" to see whether the fermentation will finish in time.

If not, there are two options: speed it up (add a culture, keep the wine on the pomace while it is warm), or be patient: the fermentation will continue in spring as the cellar warms. In that case do not add SO₂ in winter, seal the qvevri well and protect the wine from oxygen.

Paper chromatography at home

You need: chromatography paper (Whatman No. 1), micropipettes or capillaries, standards (0.3% solutions of tartaric, malic and lactic acid), the solvent (butanol, formic acid, water and bromocresol green, sold as a ready kit) and a closed container.

1. Draw a pencil line 2.5 cm from the bottom edge of the paper and mark points 2–3 cm apart.

2. Spot each point 4–5 times (drying each time); the spot should be no more than 5 mm across.

3. Staple the paper into a cylinder and stand it in the solvent in the container (1 cm deep) with the line above the liquid. Close the container.

4. After 6–8 hours (when the solvent has nearly reached the top edge) take it out and dry it in a well-ventilated place until the smell of formic acid has gone: the background turns blue-green and the acids yellow.

5. Compare the wine spots with the standards. If the malic acid spot is no longer visible, the fermentation is complete.

Common problems

• It does not start: too cold, too much SO₂, low pH or high alcohol. Check with the calculator; warm the wine and add a culture if needed.

• It stops halfway: a drop in temperature or a lack of nutrients. Stir the wine on its lees and warm it.

• Off-odours (vinegar, horse sweat, "mousy"): foreign bacteria or Brettanomyces yeast in high-pH wine. Do not leave the wine unprotected for long without malolactic fermentation; use a culture to select the bacteria.

• Too buttery: diacetyl. Leave the wine longer on the fine lees: the yeast will take up the diacetyl.

1. Why is a wine less acidic after malolactic fermentation?

Malic acid has two acidic groups, lactic acid one (pKa 3.86). Converting 1 g/L of malic acid lowers total acidity by ≈ 0.56 g/L and raises pH by 0.1–0.3.

2. Which factor most often holds back malolactic fermentation in a qvevri in winter?

Oenococcus oeni grows very slowly below 15 °C and almost stops below 10 °C. So in a qvevri it often starts in autumn while the wine is still warm, or carries on in spring.

3. On a paper chromatogram, malolactic fermentation is considered complete when…

Tartaric acid is resistant to the bacteria and its spot remains. The disappearance of the malic acid spot (Rf ≈ 0.5) means its concentration is below ≈ 0.1–0.2 g/L.

4. Why is malolactic fermentation usually not carried out in semi-sweet wine?

Lactic acid bacteria convert residual sugar into acetic acid and D-lactic acid (so-called "lactic taint"). Semi-sweet wine must therefore be protected from bacteria with SO₂ and cold.