Chapter V · The qvevri method
Why a buried qvevri does not heat up during fermentation the way an above-ground vessel does; how and how often to punch down the pomace cap; and how much carbon dioxide is released into the marani, and when it becomes life-threatening.
Model: fermentation is logistic, its rate doubles every 10 °C (≈ 9 days at 20 °C), and above 32 °C the yeast weakens. Heat is 546 J per gram of sugar. Buried qvevri: wine → wall (clay λ = 1.0) → near layer of earth (0.3 m, heat capacity 2 MJ/m³·K) → distant earth; at the top the mouth touches the marani air. Above ground: wine → wall → air (h ≈ 6 W/m²·K). An approximate, illustrative model.
The pomace cap is carried up by CO₂ bubbles and separates from the liquid: fermentation continues in the cap, but heat is poorly transferred, so the cap becomes warmer than the wine; its top layer dries out and becomes food for vinegar bacteria. Model: between punch-downs the cap's excess temperature ΔT = ΔTmax·(1 − e^(−t/6 h)), with ΔTmax ∝ fermentation activity × thickness; a punch-down resets it to zero. The "dry cap" risk grows with the time between punch-downs.
Each gram of sugar gives ≈ 0.49 g of CO₂; 1 kg of CO₂ at 15 °C is ≈ 0.54 m³. Marani concentration: dC/dt = (G − n·V·(C − 0.04%))/V, where G is the rate of CO₂ release and n the air changes per hour. CO₂ is 1.5 times heavier than air and collects in hollows, in qvevri and near the floor: there the concentration is much higher than calculated.
In the qvevri method the crushed grapes (must together with the pomace, often with the stems) are poured into the qvevri and ferment there. The qvevri is not filled to the top: during fermentation the pomace rises and forms a cap, and CO₂ and foam need room, so the qvevri is filled to about 80–85%. Fermentation usually starts naturally, with the grapes' own yeasts, although many winemakers use a "mother" (a small fermentation started a little earlier) or a pure yeast culture. During fermentation the qvevri is open or loosely covered so that the CO₂ can escape.
Alcoholic fermentation is exothermic: each gram of sugar releases ≈ 546 joules of heat (Chapter III, "Fermentation thermodynamics"). Fermenting a 22 °Brix must to dryness would, with no heat loss, raise the wine's temperature by ≈ 30 °C. In a large vessel this is dangerous: at 32–35 °C yeast weakens, fermentation may stick and aroma is lost.
An above-ground vessel loses heat only to the air. Air conducts heat poorly (heat transfer coefficient ≈ 5–10 W/m²·K), and a large vessel, whose surface is small relative to its volume, cools with difficulty.
A buried qvevri is in a different situation. It is touched on all sides by earth, which:
1. has a huge heat capacity (≈ 2 MJ/m³·K, a thousand times more than air);
2. conducts heat fairly well (moist loam ≈ 1.2 W/m·K, wet clay ≈ 1.8; dry sand only ≈ 0.4);
3. at a depth of 1–2 metres has an almost constant temperature through the year, usually 12–16 °C at harvest time.
The layer of earth around the qvevri works as a "heat buffer": it absorbs the heat of fermentation and gradually spreads it into the distant earth. So in a buried qvevri the wine's temperature rises less and more slowly during fermentation than in an above-ground vessel, and fermentation proceeds evenly, without excessive overheating. This is one of the main advantages of burial: natural temperature control without a cooling system.
Soil moisture matters too: dry, sandy earth conducts heat poorly, and a qvevri in it heats up more. Traditionally a qvevri is buried in moist, loamy earth, often in a lime mix.
Within a few hours of the start of fermentation, CO₂ bubbles carry the pomace (skins, seeds, stems) upward and form a dense layer on the surface of the liquid: the pomace cap. In a large qvevri the cap reaches a thickness of several tens of centimetres. Three processes take place in the cap:
• fermentation continues (there is must in the pomace), but heat passes poorly from the cap to the liquid, so the cap is warmer than the wine, sometimes by 5–10 °C;
• the top layer of the cap touches the air and dries out: an ideal environment for vinegar bacteria (Acetobacter) and mould;
• pomace caught in the cap no longer touches the liquid, so extraction (the transfer of colour, tannins and aroma into the wine) slows down.
So the cap must be punched down regularly: with a special wooden pole the cap is pushed into the liquid and stirred. During vigorous fermentation this is done 3–5 times a day, less often at the start and end of fermentation. Punching down cools the cap, wets it, reduces oxygen in the top layer and evens out extraction. It continues until fermentation is finished; after fermentation the pomace gradually sinks to the bottom of the qvevri.
During fermentation ≈ 0.49 g of CO₂ is released from every gram of sugar. In a 1000-litre qvevri this is ≈ 90 kg, or ≈ 50 m³ of gas: as much as the volume of an ordinary marani. CO₂ is colourless and almost odourless, 1.5 times heavier than air, and collects near the floor, in hollows and in qvevri.
| CO₂ in air | Effect |
|---|---|
| 0.04% | normal air |
| 0.5% | workplace limit (8 hours) |
| 3% | rapid breathing, headache |
| 5–8% | dizziness, confusion |
| > 10% | loss of consciousness within seconds, death |
During fermentation the space inside the qvevri above the pomace is almost pure CO₂. Putting your head into or climbing into a qvevri during fermentation, and after it until the qvevri has been well ventilated, is life-threatening: a few breaths are enough to lose consciousness. The marani must be well ventilated during fermentation, especially at floor level. The traditional "candle test" is not reliable: a candle goes out only when CO₂ is already at a level dangerous to people. An inexpensive CO₂ detector mounted near the floor is better.
1. In the "Temperature" mode enter the qvevri capacity, the must sugar and initial temperature, the temperature of the earth and of the marani air, and the soil type. The chart shows at the same time the wine temperature in a buried qvevri and in a vessel of the same size above ground, the temperature of the earth around the qvevri, and the progress of fermentation. Try dry sandy soil or a warmer must and see how the maximum temperature changes.
2. In the "Pomace cap" mode choose the number of punch-downs per day, the cap thickness (you can estimate it on the "Qvevri shape" page), the wine temperature and the fermentation phase. You will see how much the cap heats up between punch-downs and how great the risk of a dry cap is.
3. In the "Carbon dioxide" mode enter the number and capacity of qvevri, the sugar, the fermentation temperature, the marani volume and the ventilation. You will see how much CO₂ is released, at what rate, what its concentration in the marani air will be and what ventilation is needed.
1. Wash the qvevri beforehand and, if needed, burn sulphur in it (see "Home cellar: hygiene").
2. Pour the crushed grapes (with all the pomace or part of it, according to the method) into the qvevri up to 80–85% of its capacity.
3. In the first 1–3 days fermentation starts slowly. During this time stir the cap twice a day.
4. During vigorous fermentation (usually 3–10 days) punch the cap down 3–5 times a day: in the morning, at midday, in the evening and, if possible, at night. Wet the cap completely each time.
5. Every day measure the wine's temperature (below the cap, at mid-depth) and its density. If the temperature exceeds 30 °C, punch down more often and cool the marani.
6. As fermentation ends (SG ≈ 0.995, the cap gradually sinks), punch-downs become less frequent. Then the qvevri is closed: see "The Kakhetian method" and "Racking, sealing and storage".
• Never put your head into a qvevri during fermentation. Punch down with a long-handled pole, standing up.
• Keep the marani door and windows open; if the marani is underground, install a fan that draws air out from floor level.
• Install a CO₂ detector 30–50 cm above the floor.
• Climbing into a qvevri (to clean it) is allowed only after good ventilation and in the presence of a second person standing above.
1. Why does a buried qvevri stay relatively cool during fermentation?
The earth touches the qvevri on all sides and its heat capacity is enormous. An above-ground vessel loses heat only to the air, and air conducts heat poorly.
2. Why should the pomace cap be punched down several times a day?
Fermentation continues in the cap, but heat is poorly transferred. A dry, warm cap is an ideal environment for vinegar bacteria. Punching down balances all of this.
3. Why must you never put your head into or climb into a qvevri during fermentation?
CO₂ is heavier than air and fills the qvevri. A concentration above 8–10% causes loss of consciousness within seconds. Winemakers die this way every year: ventilate the marani and the qvevri well.