Chapter X · Vinegar production
The quality of finished vinegar is defined by a few numbers: total acidity, residual alcohol, SO₂ and heavy metals. The international benchmarks are the Codex Alimentarius standard for vinegar and the OIV definition of wine vinegar. This page has a compliance check, fault diagnosis and a pasteurisation calculation.
Limits: Codex STAN 162-1987: acidity ≥ 60 g/L in wine vinegar, ≥ 50 g/L in others; residual alcohol ≤ 0.5% vol (≤ 1% in wine vinegar); SO₂ ≤ 70 mg/kg; lead ≤ 1, iron ≤ 10, copper + zinc ≤ 10 mg/kg. OIV (OIV-ECO 401-2012) for wine vinegar: acidity ≥ 60 g/L, ethanol ≤ 4% vol. Acidity is stated on the label as "X%" (minimum acidity, rounded to a whole number). We could not find a separate Georgian technical regulation for vinegar; check the current requirements with the National Food Agency.
Tick every symptom you see or smell. The scores use illustrative weights; the diagnosis gives a direction and does not replace laboratory analysis.
Illustrative model: for acetic acid bacteria D₆₀ ≈ 1 min, z ≈ 7 °C, i.e. D(T) = D₆₀·10^((60 − T)/z); reduction = t / D(T). The high acidity of vinegar increases heat sensitivity. Vinegar eels (Turbatrix aceti) die quickly at 45–50 °C. Typical regimes: 60–65 °C for a few minutes, or flash 75–80 °C for ~30 s. Excess heat loses aroma (ethyl acetate, acetoin) and darkens the colour.
The main international benchmark for vinegar is the Codex Alimentarius standard for vinegar (CODEX STAN 162-1987). The International Organisation of Vine and Wine has adopted a separate definition for wine vinegar (OIV-ECO 401-2012): wine vinegar is a product fit for human consumption obtained exclusively by the acetic fermentation of wine.
| Parameter | Codex STAN 162-1987 | OIV, wine vinegar |
|---|---|---|
| Total acidity, as acetic acid | wine vinegar ≥ 60 g/L; others ≥ 50 g/L | ≥ 60 g/L |
| Residual alcohol | ≤ 0.5% vol; wine vinegar ≤ 1% vol | ≤ 4% vol |
| Origin of the acid | only by biological fermentation | only by acetic fermentation of wine |
| SO₂ | ≤ 70 mg/kg | — |
| Arsenic; lead | ≤ 1 mg/kg; ≤ 1 mg/kg | — |
| Iron; copper + zinc | ≤ 10 mg/kg; ≤ 10 mg/kg | — |
Under Codex, the acid of vinegar must come only from biological fermentation; adding synthetic acetic acid is not allowed. The label names the raw material in the vinegar's name ("vinegar of X"; for several raw materials, in descending order of proportion), and next to the name the total acidity, "X%", where X is the minimum acidity in g/100 mL rounded to a whole number.
In the EU, wine vinegar is listed as one of the categories of grapevine products in Part II of Annex VII to Regulation 1308/2013, while detailed quality requirements for vinegar are often set by member states' national rules.
We could not find a separate technical regulation for vinegar in Georgia; vinegar, as a food, is subject to the general requirements of food safety and labelling. If you plan to sell vinegar, check the current requirements with the National Food Agency and at matsne.gov.ge. This page is for information and is not legal advice.
Wine vinegar is not just a solution of acetic acid in water. Many components of the wine remain in it: tartaric acid and potassium, glycerol, phenolic compounds, minerals, and the by-products of acetification: acetoin, ethyl acetate, acetaldehyde. These substances give the vinegar its aroma and "body" and also indicate its origin: diluted synthetic acetic acid lacks them.
To check authenticity, laboratories measure fixed acidity, extract, glycerol, tartaric acid and potassium, and use stable isotope analysis (¹³C, ²H) to distinguish synthetic from biological acetic acid. The OIV compendium of methods of analysis for vinegars contains the procedures for determining total, fixed and volatile acidity, alcohol and other parameters.
1. Vinegar eels (Turbatrix aceti): roundworms ~1–2 mm long that develop in unpasteurised, open vessels and feed on bacteria. They are harmless, but make the vinegar hazy and unacceptable. Filtering and heating (above 50 °C) remove them.
2. Excess bacterial cellulose: growth of the "mother", a slimy mass; the vinegar must be filtered.
3. Over-oxidation: after the ethanol runs out, acidity falls (see "Vinegar biochemistry and microbiology").
4. Stuck acetification: cold, SO₂, too much alcohol or too few live bacteria.
5. Excess ethyl acetate: a glue smell; it appears at low acidity when other microorganisms are active.
6. Acetaldehyde: a sharp "green apple" smell, a sign of oxygen shortage.
7. Yeast film and mould: at low acidity; mouldy vinegar is usually discarded.
8. Metal casse: iron and copper salts make vinegar hazy and dark; vinegar dissolves metal, so only glass, ceramic, wooden or stainless steel vessels are used.
9. Colloidal haze: pectin, proteins; fining and filtration.
Finished vinegar is filtered and often pasteurised to stop the growth of bacteria, eels and "mother". The thermal death of microorganisms is described by D and z values:
$$D(T) = D_{ref}\cdot 10^{(T_{ref} - T)/z},\qquad \text{reduction} = \frac{t}{D(T)}$$
where D is the time in which the number of live cells falls tenfold and z the temperature rise that reduces D tenfold. The calculator uses illustrative values (D₆₀ ≈ 1 min, z ≈ 7 °C); the high acidity of vinegar makes bacteria more heat-sensitive. Typical regimes are 60–65 °C for a few minutes or flash 75–80 °C for ~30 seconds. Excess heat loses volatile aroma (ethyl acetate, acetoin) and darkens the colour, so after pasteurisation the vinegar must be cooled quickly.
Because of its high acidity, vinegar is itself a preservative and, stored properly, keeps for years. In an opened bottle a new "mother" or haze may appear; this is harmless and is removed by filtering. Vinegar is stored in full, tightly closed glass bottles in a cool, dark place.
Codex Alimentarius, Regional Standard for Vinegar (CODEX STAN 162-1987); OIV, Resolution OIV-ECO 401-2012 "Wine vinegar"; OIV, Compendium of International Methods of Analysis for Vinegars; Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council, Annex VII, Part II; S. Tesfaye et al., Wine vinegar: technology, authenticity and quality evaluation (Trends Food Sci. Technol., 2002); L. Solieri, P. Giudici (eds.), Vinegars of the World (Springer, 2009). The fault weights and the pasteurisation D/z values are illustrative.
1. In the "Compliance check" mode, choose the type of vinegar and enter the analysis results: acidity, residual alcohol, SO₂ and metals. The cards show the comparison with the Codex and OIV limits, and the label card shows how to state the acidity (rounded down to a whole number, so that the stated minimum does not exceed the real value). The chart shows all parameters as a percentage of the limit.
2. In the "Faults" mode, tick the symptoms to get the most likely fault, a second possibility and a recommendation.
3. In the "Pasteurisation" mode, enter the temperature, holding time and desired reduction to get the log reduction, the time needed and whether eels are killed.
• Wine vinegar, 6.3%, 0.4% alcohol → meets both standards; label "6% acidity".
• Wine vinegar, 5.4% → does not qualify for the name "wine vinegar" (≥ 6% needed).
• 65 °C, 2 min → ~10-log reduction (illustrative), eels are killed.
• Vinegar eels are visible against light in a clear bottle: fine, moving "threads". Cover the acetification vessel with gauze and keep it clean.
• After pasteurisation, cool the vinegar quickly and bottle it in full bottles.
• Do not use metal taps or vessels in contact with vinegar.
• Have the acidity and residual alcohol of vinegar for sale measured in an accredited laboratory.
1. What minimum acidity is required of wine vinegar by Codex and the OIV?
Both organisations require ≥ 60 g/L acidity (as acetic acid) for wine vinegar; Codex requires ≥ 50 g/L for other vinegars.
2. What are "vinegar eels"?
They are roundworms ~1–2 mm long; harmless, but they make the vinegar hazy and unacceptable. Heating to 50 °C and filtering removes them.
3. What does "6%" on a vinegar label mean?
Under Codex, the minimum total acidity (g/100 mL as acetic acid) is stated next to the vinegar's name as "X%".